Reviews for Original Michelangelo Pizzeria-Restaurant Eastport in Eastport, NY

Ordered 2 chicken parm heroes. Got home and found 2 eggplant parm heroes. Called in and was told that?s what was ordered. I... explained that no one in my home eats eggplant and was told too bad. The sauce sucks and everything is way overpriced. ClownSabastian at the counter is a tool Read more

Compared to all the other Michelangelo?s this is by far the best. The cheese looks fresh every time I walk in. I highly... recommend getting a Buffalo Pie!!! Keep it up guys. Read more

Best tasting Italian food in the Hamptons at any price and theirs is very reasonable. They make every Italian dish you could... want. Great strong drinks at non ripoff prices. Speedy service all the time. Read more

$20 for a regular pie? That?s ridiculous and overpriced for no reason. Their regular pie isn?t even worth the $20. Always comes... out undercooked, super greasy and floppy. Place has been garbage for years. Everything overpriced and the staff doesn?t know howto help people when they walk in. What a shame. Read more

WORST EXPERIENCE EVER!!! THESE PEOPLE ARE RUDE AND ARROGANT!!! I brought my ladies there from work after one craving pizza. The... older guy behind the counter rushed and rushed us to order, we weren?t talking fast enough and swooshed us down to the cashier.I told him I didn?t order yet he rudely replied, yes you did you ordered the eggplant. Noooo that was for one of my Individuals.He then tells me again to go down . As he kept helping others, the pizza I had wanted was taken from someone 3 spots behind me.And?.. when my lady FINALLY got her meal it was wrong and he argued at our table, saying she said penne. I said and she saidNOOOOO we both said veggie. NEVER AGAIN WILL I GET ANYTHING FROM THEM FOR HOW THEY TREATED MY LADIES who are out here in thecommunity doing the best they can!!! AND??. THE JERK NEVER EVEN APOLOGIZED FOR ME NOT BEING ABLE TO ORDER MY DINNER!!! Read more

Walked in to the cashier laughing about someone wanting to speak to the manager. $50 for a salad, hero and penne. And yes, they... did forget my chicken - it was ordered but don?t worry, they didn?t charge me. So I guess I would have gotten free chicken ifthey made my order correctly? Unfortunately I didn?t get a receipt for cash payment. Terrible service. Over priced. Read more

Great Italian restaurant ????! If you looking for a cozy place, try this one. Love tbe atmosphere inside, and the stuff are... friendly! Food is great and worth to try it! Read more

As always, a great meal at at great value. My favorite is the Clams Luciano and Chicken Scarpiello with Sausage and Hot Cherry... Peppers... Read more