Reviews for The Plum Tomato, East Lyme, CT in East Lyme, CT

Ordered 2 times on the phone came to pick up twice and no order.. the cashier who I placed my order with twice ! Same person !... Wait 3 times . ? I don?t see your order? physically spoke to the same person in person and once on the phone. Maybe don?t hire? Absolutely trash service for the price I?d think we would actually get some service.. do not order here. Ghetto in Eastlyme .Burger King took our order and got it right the first time.. Read more

Loved their pizza. Thin crispy crust, well seasoned sauce, toppings roasted and good quality, not greasy. Checks all the... boxes! Read more

Great pizza, not greasy like many other places. Was greeted with a smile when picking up our takeout order. Great experience.

We?ve been to the other Plum Tomatoes but this was our first time at this location and it was wonderful. The staff was so... friendly and helpful with my food allergies! The food was absolutely delicious and we will definitely be back. Read more

Dave is amazing! Service was almost better than the food. Pictured is the Ali without cheese but with sauce. Definitely add... sauce but go vegan cheese at a minimum or the sandwich is way too messy. Delicious loose sausage and peppers on Gluten-freebread! Read more

Blazing Saddle, best pizza, strongly recommended. Get rid of the grinder rolls, give me the real Fatti bread.

Me and my fiancé ordered food for our wedding and it was great, there was something for everyong to enjoy and my wives family... LOVED it!!! Had a great experience with these guys. 10/10 would recommend for anyone looking for the highest quality of foodaround!!! Read more

YUM! For our first order we tried the Cheeseburger Dilla, Knucklebread (gluten free), cheese pizza & chicken nachos. Large... portions, ample sized side of salsa & sour cream. The Dilla dipping sauce & knucklebread dipping sauce are amazing! Largefresh roasted whole garlics on the knucklebread. The GF crust was delicious. We look forward to going back & trying somedesserts next time. Read more