Reviews for Irish Coffee Pub in East Islip, NY
Beautiful and Very impressive place. Potato cream soup and my steak was amazing. I had just wine, but based on my friend?s... recommendation ?White Russian? drink is the best)) But what made me more happy is service. Our server was Mila, omg she is thefunniest and kindest person in the world I swear ???? Mila definitely is essential part of the dinner. Thank You Read more
Pricey but worth! I was there Tuesday evening there were six of us and we all left happy. There is not a bad table in the... restaurant. I had the house Chardonnay and could not leave without finding what kind they served. The service was excellent asusual. Great place for a special night or just hanging with friends! Read more
From my wife's BOLI review: The Irish Coffee Pub Where do I even begin? The Pub was a dream come true. When we first got... engaged, one of my good friends told me and my husband (oops almost wrote fiancé!) to list our top three priorities for ourwedding. Food was at the top of our list and boy did the Pub deliver! We had heard good things about the restaurant from familymembers, but we had never been there and I had never even heard of it. After researching it some more, my husband and I just hada good feeling about the place. I even got butterflies when pulling into the parking lot for our first meeting. I guess it?strue what they say...when you?ve found your wedding venue, you just know! Stephen (one of the Pub owners) welcomed us with openarms. We could tell that he and the other owners pour their hearts and souls into the restaurant. The second floor had beennewly renovated for events and Stephen gave us a very thorough tour. He even served us a complimentary meal! Stephen and histeam were on top of things every step of the way. Stephen created the perfect timeline and floor plan...my uncle even commentedon how seamlessly everything flowed in terms of timing and how well the layout worked for dancing and mingling. Megan andPatrick were our maitre d?s and they ensured that everything was in place. We delivered so many picture frames and decorativeitems and somehow they found the perfect spot for every little thing. They went above and beyond and made sure we ate and weretaken care of. Every guest has raved about the food so far, especially the potato soup ???? I keep telling everyone that the Pubwould be a great spot for not only weddings but also date nights. We will definitely be back for anniversaries and other specialevents. Please go check out this gem of a restaurant in East Islip! You won?t be disappointed. Read more
Stopped at the Irish Coffee Pub to have , what else, A Classic Irish Coffee and a slice of cake. Delicious. Host was so... gracious. Talkative and informative and inviting. Very cozy place. Packed. Old school place. If you like piano music, comfortfood and great company, stop by for dinner or dessert. I'm glad we did. Will be back for dinner for sure. Read more
Always exceptional?..Service is great. The vibe remains classic and the food is excellent. Pro tip I tried last night?. Ordered... a mixed bowl of beef barley and potato soup? the best of both worlds! Read more
The Christmas decorations were gorgeous. It appeared that they did not have enough wait staff for our party of 40. Some of us... got our food right away while others had to wait. The steak was very salty and the chicken was ok. The cream of potato soupwas excellent, the salad was doused in dressing so couldnt eat it. The apple crisp with vanilla ice cream and whipped cream wasvery good. Will try again when less busy June 2021 Came here again for an event. Appears that when there are more than a fewpeople, the food isnt as good. The wait staff kept forgetting to give one person at our table his dessert. I asked for decafcoffee twice and it never came. The steak was good but the sauce very salty, the croutons in the salad was a bit stale and theCaeser salad had too much dressing. The chicken was a bit tough. Maybe next time, I will come with just one person and seehow it will be then Read more
Had my son's first birthday here this last weekend and overall was happy with the experience. The service could have been... slightly better and more organized as some plates weren't served all around. However, Katie and Meagan were lovely to deal within planning the party and I was even given the whole upstairs and run of the floor for my party and activities at no extracharge because I was the only party at the time. The food was good and the price very fair. Will use them again in the future. Read more
This was the first time my family decided to dine out on Thanksgiving. Unfortunately the experience was nothing to celebrate... about except for the fact that we were together, happy and healthy. A lot to be thankful for. Most of us had the turkey dinneror steak. Not one of us was impressed with the turkey dinner. The sides were fine but the turkey was thinly sliced and rolledaround stuffing. It was so obvious that it was processed meat. So disappointed because myself and the quests were lookingforward to this Thanksgiving turkey meal. The steak was very good except for my brother who ordered medium rare but receivedwell done. This was corrected immediately. What we were very pleased with was the beauty, decor and cleanliness of thisrestaurant. The staff was warm and welcoming and we were seated promptly. Our server Patrick was amazing. Very patient,professional, accommodating and never stopped moving . Patrick is an asset to your establishment! Everyone was happy withtheir appetizers, salad, soup, sides, desserts and cocktails. So overall it was a pleasant experience! Read more