Reviews for Cittanuova in East Hampton, NY

Had to ask to find my waiter on a Friday lunch three times. Not once did he check on me. Not a single time. I still left a... solid 20% tip. And this place cannot cook a burger to save their life. Other dishes are decent (especially the Pollo Sandwich atlunch). My Medium burger came out close to Rare. Sent it back. Waited 15 mins. Same burger that I had bitten into and cut intocame back rendering it impossible to eat with my hands so I had to eat with a knife and fork ???????? If you fail on firstattempt then remake the burger. Read more

So a couple days ago I came to this restaurant as there was the only avalible seat. This is a great restaurant with amazing... variety. And the food is delicious. The only flaw I must say is their prices. It is quite expensive there. And service speedcould be a little bit better. But overall a good restaurant. Read more

Adorable little Italian restaurant! Perfect for a lunch date! Must get the margarita pizza and Cesar salad which they make their... own dressing for it! Read more

Delicious food! Beautiful scenery! Our waiter Scott was very attentive and kind. We will definitely be back!

Waited way too long for a sandwich ! 60 minutes! Waiter was inexperienced and inattentive which ruined our meal. Food good but... the salad was a very small portion. Come on! What do greens cost!? Read more

Good place for a meal. We chose the outdoor seating and something from the roof kept falling off constantly. Because the... restaurant wasn?t busy, there wasn?t any one to hear it out. Overall a nice place! Read more

Delightful lunch outdoors. Highly recommend their Octopus appetizer. Other nice dishes include the Bolognese pasta, Kale pizza... and chocolate bread pudding (enough for two). Their Americano was watery, but all else enjoyable. Read more

Every dish was very tasty and well cooked. The meatball starter had a really nice mix of meats and the marinara was great. The... steak was cooked to perfection and the side of Brussels was really well seasoned with Modena. Thoroughly enjoyed the food inCittanuova and I would highly recommend to give it a try. The staff were also nice and professional. Read more