Reviews for Casey's in Earlham, IA
If you?re getting anything here, make sure it?s only gas. I stopped for gas, a drink & few snacks. The pizza was probably out... for a while, but whatever. I drink my sweet tea & disgusting is an understatement. I come to find my sweet tea drink was expiredafter already pulling back onto the highway. The bottle had black at the bottom that floated when turned upside down. Routineexpiration checks are not being done when restocking clearly. Expiration date 8/10/2021, purchased 9/2/2021. Read more
Store is always dirty, ice cream machine is always out of order. Sharina is a horrible manager. Always make sure to get gas or... ANYTHING ELSE you might need, THE NEXT TOWN OVER. I garenttee casey's in Earlham will be out. And the manager will just brushyou off, if she's in the store and not outside smoking cigarettes. Read more
Picked up some breakfast pizza out of their warmer. It was hot, fresh, and tasty. All of their employees were wearing masks... and wearing them correctly which was nice to see. Read more
Rating applies to all Casey's, but especially this one. Very hit-and-miss quality-wise, selection-wise, clean-wise, etc. Use... their bathrooms at your own risk. Good luck to you if you need something after 11PM. And some of us haven't forgotten about thefuel price gouging scandal after the 9/11 attacks...nor WILL we forget. Read more
Clean. Limited selection and space. Good gas prices and kind service.
The person responsible for those cinnamon rolls should have her own TV show! Wow, all that icing, that was simply awesome. I... used their microwave to heat it up a little. Oh man, after I ate that roll my eyes rolled back in my head and I was on a sugarhigh all the way to Wyoming! It was a nice surprise for a random gas stop off the Interstate. Read more
Waited over 15 minutes for sub to be made after bringing it to workers attention was told "it would be 5 -10 more minutes... because he had more pizzas to make". We didnt wait and were not the only customers that left unhappy. I'll spend my $ elsewhere.2/20/17 Read more
Almost always great service. Excellent pizza, cheese sticks and pork tenderloins.