Reviews for The Old Mill in Dothan, AL

Me and a buddy stopped by here to eat on 11/7/22. We are here playing the RTJ golf trail. Annie C. is an outstanding waitress.... The food was excellent. I can see why it's a popular place for the locals. I would definitely go back if I'm in the area. Read more

This was our first time at The Old Mill. With our lunch we received yummy hot yeast rolls. We both enjoyed our lunches but the... service was what I really want to comment on. Our server Elizabeth was so very attentive. Elizabeth was right on top of ourorder and any of our request. Unfortunately these days customer service is is very lacking but not if you go to The Old Mill andare fortunate enough to have Elizabeth as your server. Read more

The bread pudding is made from their homemade yeast rolls. 10/10 would eat again.

Quant and cozy. Food was delicious, service fantastic! Very pleased and would definitely recommend you visit. I had the crab... claw dinner. Way too much food! Lol Read more

Fast service, fabulous food and fantastic staff. We were recommended this place and it did not let down. All the food was... wonderful, buns came out hot and they have a few "featured cocktails." Better when forgot our take away, it was waiting at thefront counter for us. Read more

Great dinner and great service thanks to Erin R. The Mahi Mahi was on point. Great food, great service and great drinks.

I had the stuff Grouper and it was Very Delicious. Everyone else enjoyed their steaks and crab claws. The service was excellent.... They open at 4:30 & fill up fast. Be prepared to wait if you don't get there when they open. Read more

A very friendly staff (always the first thing I pay attention to) that is very prompt. The food was excellent. The Mahi was very... flavorful and cooked perfectly. The vegetable kabob was surprisingly delicious (I would love to know what they baste it with).Even the fried mushroom appetizer was great and had a great texture. My partner had the steak, just as good if not better. Therestraint has a very homey feel to it that is warm and inviting. Dressed up or down you would feel welcome there. There was avery cozy bar area that looked great. 5 stars for a local steak and seafood house that exceeded my expectations. I willdefinitely be back. Read more