Reviews for Bennolli's Pizza in Delafield, WI
I have been trying to support this shop because it?s local and family owned. However, while the pizza is good it is not... outstanding and you can get same or better taste in the area for a fraction of their price. So that?s problem one, price is muchhigher. And two, please forget about getting salad here please! For example Greek salad that cost $7.00 is composed of lots oflettuce and few croutons and other identified veggies? Who heard of Greek salad that has lettuce and croutons. Oh well I do hopethey make prices more reasonable as at this point there is no reason to really go here as their pizza doesn?t really stand out.Sorry I feel I am being harsh but I am just being realistic. Read more
Staff coughed and coughed all over food, I complained by phone and told would not be charged for pizza thst went in the... garbage, but was. Called twice more with no response. Owner should take more responsibility. Read more
Arrived for lunch today at 11am when they were supposed to open. Staff did not open doors until 11:05am. Staff seemed very... disgruntled for having to be there and ignored us for several minutes. Personal pan pizzas and any kind of sticks were notavailable. We decided to leave. Read more
Had a gift card to Bennolis so I decided to order a pizza. We told them we would pick up at 7pm ( one hour after we... ordered)because that?s when we would end up being in the area. Once I picked it up I went straight home , 15minutes away andthe pizza was COLD. I was disappointed. The part that really upset me about this VISIT was using my gift card. Turns out itLOSES VALUE after a year!! It was a $25 giftcard and there was only $7 on it. I got it 1.5 years ago. Apparently there?s writingon the gift card that explains this. It?s unbelievable & there?s no reason to do this to customers money. Read more
Small place with 3 tables. The workers are helpful and friendly. The kids enjoyed watching them making the pizzas. The pizza... tasted good and the parmesan bread sticks were fluffy and delicious. Prices were inline with other non chain pizza placesnearby. Read more