Reviews for The Gin Mill in Decatur, IL
Amazing Apps and Steaks! We had a awesome experience at the Gin Mill. From our waitresses Alexis to the great food! When had the... Bang Bang Shrimp, Alligator Bites and a couple ribeyes. Don't forget to get some of that delicious garlic bread too. DeliciousFood Updated: Had the Lamb Chops and Rasta Pasta. The Lamb Chops tasted so good and were so tender! Read more
Had lunch today, 9-16-2022, and Jessica G. was our waitress. She was very knowledgeable and extremely courteous. We each had a... half and half. Lobster Bisque and salad and the soup and Cuban Sandwich with side of fries. We indulged with a Creme Brulee andTriple Chocolate Cake. The food was great and the service was prefect. It was nice to see they had a good crowd with few if anyempty tables. Definitely give the restaurant and Jessica G. five stars. Can't wait to go back. Read more
Matthew was a great server! My steak was perfectly made, the strawberry vinaigrette dressing was amazing, loved the bruschetta... and the old fashioned was good! Truffle fries were nice and crispy but didn't taste the truffle very much. Read more
Nice atmosphere and friendly staff. Had the swordfish special; which was okay but not the best. The twice backed potato is... absolutely awesome. The worst thing was the smell of sewer sitting outside on the patio. Not sure what?s going on but there is afrequent burst of foul odor that spoils dinner. Also, I feel like this attracts the flys which made it hard to eat. Read more
Overall a nice atmosphere with friendly staff. Food was good but not great. Hawaiian burger had overwhelming taste of pineapple,... a thinner slice may have helped it be more balanced. Bacon on burger was undercooked and a little soggy. Burger patty itself wasvery good as well as the Korean BBQ sauce. Truffle fries were also a little strong in flavor for my taste. Seems like a nicerupscale option for the area. Read more
Went for lunch and ordered soup and a half sandwich. Waiter recommended the smoked broccoli cheddar and I chose the Cuban... sandwich. The smoke flavor of the soup was a little over bearing but the sandwich was solid. Seems to be the nicest place intown and it knows it but it may be trying a little too hard. I would have to come for dinner to know for sure. Read more
This was our first time eating there and it was suggested to us by a friend. The food was excellent! The atmosphere was... relaxing. The wait staff were very good! All the food was great but I highly recommend the Bruchetta and the pineappleupside-down cocktail!! Delicious! Read more
We ate upstairs on the balcony. It was almost too dark to read the menu. But it had a good ambiance. I got the bacon jalapeno... burger, cooked just as I asked and it was delicious!! My father-in-law got the lamb chops and they were to die for! Mybrother-in-law got the rib eye, which was so tender and flavorful! Alexis was a fabulous server! My only complaint is thehouse salad had onion was cut so small and it was so dark I couldn't pick it off, but the main flavor of the salad was onion. Iwould have removed it if I could have. My suggestion would be to leave it in bigger pieces. Read more