Reviews for The Original Anthony's Pizza in DeBary, FL

As a New Yorker I?ve got nothing bad to say about this pizza! It?s not exact but it?s so darn close I?m really happy! Bright... acidic sauce, and not too much of it, lets the taste of the high quality cheese shine. It?s the crust that can?t be replicated,I?m positive it?s the New York water that gives the distinctive flavor, but it was really good! I?ll definitely be back! Read more

I came in a got a pizza and wings. The food is spectacular. It's hard to get a good pie in the south but clearly they have it... figured out. You really get your moneys worth here. The pizza has a really nice unique flavor. Read more

Amazing Service! Thank you For the Great Hospitality! Highly Recommended! Pizza is So Delicious! You will not Be Disappointed!!!

I don?t usually write reviews but I have to say every time we come we are treated like family . They remember our names and what... we like to drink. The staff is very personable Tiffany and Austin have always gone above and beyond for us . We will continue tomake Anthony?s a regular spot we come to often. Read more

I keep trying to support a local business but it seems that with every recent order it gets worse. The positive is that it at... least tastes okay. But we ordered a double pepperoni pizza and they skipped out on half of the pepperoni (not the first timethey shorted the toppings), the pizza was so uneven that I couldn't even pick up my slice because it was so thin. So afterpaying with a tip and fees a total of $48 I find myself adding my own pepperoni and putting the pizza back in the oven to cookthe bottom more. Do better! Read more

Love the atmosphere and the people who work there were really nice. I ordered and was warned that it may take 40 minutes for my... food to get out which was totally fine. I asked for extra sauce on my large pepperoni but hardly got any sauce. I also orderedspaghetti and meat sauce and an order of meat balls. Got them both in the spaghetti. They were for two different people whichwas not a big deal. Overall it was pretty decent. But I will be checking my pizza before I leave the restaurant next time. Read more

Buyer beware!! This business charges $1.00 for you to use your credit card to pay for your food. Seriously, They are a business... and are responsible for those credit card fees by choosing to own a business. How about hide the fee in the cost of the food-that is actually very good instead of telling the customers it costs $1.00 to run your card. We are supporting them and theywant to put that fee onto the us. I think the owner needs to learn business management skills. I just wanted to let you know-BRING CASH instead of them taking your hard earned dollar away from you for nothing. Read more

Great one day, dry and tasteless the next. Thought I found a replacement for Blue Springs Pizza when I ordered the next day and... got this garbage. Called and they said sorry, no explanation no resolution. Never ordering here again Read more