Reviews for Matero's Pub & Pizza in Custer, WI
Always consistent amazing food and drinks along with great hospitality!! Love it!!
Excellent Shrimp Pizza and cheese curds. Staff was very friendly and helpful
Johnny is the best bartender we have ever had. Great drinks and fantastic sense of humor! Food was great!
I?ve been here 3 times now. Once for Friday fish fry. The food was great, service mediocre. The second time I had spaghetti. It... was nothing super special but was good and the service that nice was good. The third time we went for pizza. We had the samewaitress as our first visit. We ordered a meat pizza (a special on their menu, not a customized one). The bartender brought usour pizza out and we didn?t realize it was the wrong one before he left. We went to get him back and let him know our order wasincorrect.. he gave us the option to eat the wrong pizza or wait for the correct one. We were starving so said we?d eat it (itdidn?t belong to anyone else.). After a couple minutes our waitress came out and said she wrote the order down correct butentered it in the system wrong, and that she?d go correct it. We said no, that?s fine we will just eat the wrong one (anotherwaitress had offered a $5 discount.) our waitress said no she?d go put the correct order in as well as an order of cheese curdsfor us. Before we could object a 2nd time she was gone. A few minutes later she came back out and said ?the boss? told her totake the wrong pizza back. We had already eaten 5 slices of it. We ended up getting the curds for free- which whatever, wedidn?t even order them. While the food is good I don?t think we?ll be back. Read more
The pizza burger deluxe sandwich was excellant. Our server Stacey was great too. We are mever disappointed with the food,... service & friendz at Materos. Mark & Debra Oksiuta Read more
Delicious hot beef sandwich with generous salad. Fish fry is very good. Great cheese curds, meatballs & jalapeno popper... hordoerves. Great waitstaff too!! Read more
Pizza was really good, crust was perfect. Fan of the pizza sauce they used, love the flavor. Nice large open clean place with a... friendly staff. We called our pizza order in about 10 min before we arrived, pizza was at the table before I drank half mydrink. If your in the area, give the pizza a try Read more
Best Pizza I have had in quite some time. Awesome Sauce and Flavor. Fast Service and Very Friendly Staff. Will definitely go... back. Thank You Cousin Marc Stalter for posting this place on your Facebook. Read more