Reviews for Pizza Mill in Custer, SD
We had the regular crust Towering Timber (Supreme) pizza, with a side salad. The salad was just ok, with a packaged dressing. ... But the pizza was delicious! The sauce and sausage was a bit spicy, which I like. The veggies were fresh, with just a littlecrunch to the green pepper. The thin crust was just the right mix of crunchy and chewy. The server was very nice andattentive. Would recommend. Read more
The owner was incredibly rude when I said the pizza was burnt and asked to have another made. Her excuse was because I was an... hour late picking it up. Then said it?s made in a brick oven and wasn?t going to make another. After saying previous ordersweren?t charred top and bottom, the response she gave was, ? I?ll go ahead and refund your money and we?ll partways.? Seriously? Part ways? It was a pizza, not a date gone bad! Very very rude. Read more
This place was AMAZING. Their pizza is phenomenal. My family and I will definitely be back. You will not be sorry about this... being your lunch or dinner option!???? Read more
Delicious, great service, and clean! Indoor and outdoor seating available. This was the best food we had in Custer. I would... definitely recommend and go back. YUM! Read more
Umm yes just stop here !! The pizza is delicious ????!!! We chose gyro ???? & Philly!!! We almost ate the entire pizza before we... got back to the cabin!!! They were so nice and stayed late for us ! We had no idea they closed @ 8. Aleah was very helpful &sweet!!!! 10 out of 10! They have inside & outside seating ! Something on the menu for everyone! I just want to add everythingon this pizza was FRESH !! Hard to find ! Thank you Read more
We just randomly stopped without doing research just so we could feed our four hungry wolves, and so glad we did! The pizza was... excellent; it was super duper clean and cozy, and everyone was very friendly. I'm gluten free, and it was the best gluten freepizza I've had. Kiddos had a regular cheese pizza, and it was also kid and husband approved, very cheesy ???? Pictured is thegluten free pizza. Read more
Amazing place, if you enjoy pizza you will love what they have to offer. They are super nice, their building is super clean and... lovely, and their prices are great for what they serve. Definitely a must visit if you are in town, you won't regret it. Read more
The pizza was fantastic! Crust was very thin on the bottom and rolled up thick on the edge. I'd recommend a fork and knife over... picking up the pieces as it's so thin. The outer crust was very light and flaky, very tasty. The sauce, cheese and toppings weredelicious. We tried a supreme and a one topping and they were both very good. Thinking about other pizzas that are my all timefavorites, this place might crack the top 5. I will be back next time I'm in the area and we'll see if they can replicate theexperience before I cement it in my top 5 but I'll definitely be thinking about it until then. We came on a Saturday afternoonin mid October, they were steady but not busy. Our service was fast, the restaurant and restroom was clean. Read more