Reviews for Closed for the Season - Sage Creek Grille in Custer, SD

The service was great! We really enjoyed our beef and bison burgers. Highly recommend this place to anyone

Sage Creek Grille is a quaint restaurant in downtown Custer with solid food. Service was good, ambiance was cozy and our food... overall was an enjoyable experience. We had the Mohammara to start, and while it says on the menu it?s spicy, I would call itmore sweet. The overwhelming flavor is more curry than spicy. We also ordered the Asian Shrimp & Rice and Cajun Fettucini. TheShrimp and Rice was spicy with a strong lemongrass flavor. The fettuccini was our best dish. Sauce was wonderful, vegetableswere cooked perfectly and the noodles were Al dente. The one thing missing from this dish is a piece of crusty bread to eat withthe pasta sauce. Would visit again! Read more

The standard of service and attention to detail with everything from refilling a glass to cleaning off tables between customers... was amazing, far far above average! We had the walnut and blue cheese appetizer to start and it was fantastic! Read more

Best restaurant food we had in 3 weeks time! Finally some fish (salmon). Good quality! This after 3 weeks of travel through 5... States? Read more

We stopped for lunch with our family of six. Everyone loved the food and the service was excellent. All of our entrees were... perfect. The burgers were tasty and well seasoned the salad was fresh. I added the grilled salmon, which was a great choice. Theyoungest child got cheese pizza and he liked it. 10/10! Hope to stop again some day. Read more

Everything about this place is wonderful! The food- excellently conceived, prepared and executed- such a standout in a small... town. The staff- warm, friendly, efficient- I haven't seen a restaurant staff work that week together since before the pandemic.Atmosphere- laid back and welcoming. The price - just right for the high quality you get. Going to Custer? Make time to grab ameal here. Read more

We are here for dinner while on vacation in the Black Hills area. The food was amazing, the staff were attentive and positive,... and this was the best meal out we have had as a family in a long time! Dinner entrees were fairly priced with generous portionsand wonderful flavor options. The kids meals (separate menu) were $6-7 each and well worth it. We tried the Mohamarra appetizer(like a fancy hummus, but better!) and for dinner we had the angel hair pasta with sun dried tomato basil butter (my daughteradded bacon bits that were actual pieces of real bacon, not just bits), the Asian Chili Pepper Shrimp and Rice, and the BourbonStreet Cajun Fettuccine with shrimp. All were awesome. We would definitely eat here again! Read more

Edit: Had Lunch & went back for Dinner!!! Everything is good here. Walleye was super & the shrimp appetizer rocked! Delicious... food & great vibe + fantastic service = awesome restaurant!! Soup of the Day was amazing?.carmelized onions, carrots, & lentils???? Read more