Reviews for EATalia on Hudson in Croton-On-Hudson, NY
We arrived with a group of hungry and tired photographers after a 2.5 hrs photo walk in a nearby state park. The friendly staff... was able to accommodate us and we had large plates of delicious Italian food. One suggestion. After seven miles of walking inthe sun, we like pitchers of water on the table which we were not able to get. I understand that the business wants to sellbeverages. I will tip generously for water. Other than that an excellent experience. Read more
Beautiful little restaurant. We had the chicken parmesan (to go)! It was authentic, deliciously amazing and a huge portion! My... husband said that inside was beautifully decorated and very clean! We highly recommend this restaurant ?? Read more
Astounded. That's all I can say. There were some errors on our bill and I asked about them. The waiter sent over the owner... and he said the "open food" item was for the extra bread we asked for. I questioned that - $10 for bread? - and said I didn'twant to pay that. He literally yelled at us in front of all the diners. Without even trying to explain the charge, heimmediately pulled both guns and began to say how hard he works, and he didn't charge for the butter (they only give oil) andhe's been there ten years and on and on. I was dumbfounded - lost for words - which is definitely not me. He even used the Fword. Seriously - get a grip. Our bill with tip was $140 - no beverages, just water and no veg or salad. For two pasta platesand two appetizers. I tried to explain there's a way to talk to customers but he was having none of it. He told the waiter toshow us the door. Definitely will not be back and will make sure others know this poor service happened. Read more
WAY overpriced. The shrimp cocktail for $16 had 4 shrimp!!! And they were subpar. The soup was so salty I couldn?t eat it. The... pizza tasted like frozen dough. The one decent dish was stuffed mushrooms. (4 tiny mushrooms for $18). So for 4 appetizers and apizza I spent $100 (before tip) when it tasted like something I would pay $50 for. Will never go back, don?t waste your money. Read more
Nice Family style restaurant with good wooden detailed ceiling. The place looks a little outdated. The food infact was... delicious and the portion size was huge. We loved the flavor and cherish each bite. Especially I am a vegetarian and theyaccommodate and custom made the food according to my liking.. Read more
Amazing Italian restaurant with a great staff and very friendly owner. Generous portions!!! The veal Milanese was a great... twist and our shared pizza as good as any pizzeria. Read more
So I came in when they were in the middle of serving a large party. Constantly was overlooked by the waiter. Waiter was not... attentive at all. That?s fine. Ordered lasagna which should have been easy enough. Waited 50 minutes for it. Looks raw. Shouldbe ashamed to serve this. They presented me with a dish that had 2 lasagna sheets at most topped with a bunch of cheese. Lookedlike slop you wouldn?t even feed an animal. Unacceptable at an Italian restaurant. Worst service I?ve had in a while. Will notbother to come back. I?ve had better lasagna from the local pizzeria by my house. Left hungry as it wasn?t edible. Read more
The owner is one of the angriest meanest people I?ve ever met. The food was fine and the waitress was nice, but supporting a... literal DEMON will be a no from me. I don?t need to pay extra to be abused. I recommend the Olive Garden over this cause atleast you?re family there. The owner adds random fees to the bill and they all say ?open container?, if you ask him about thesefees he will come into the dining room and scream at you in front of all the diners. Other reviews confirm that this is notunusual. Read more