Reviews for Tall Man’s Homemade Ice Cream in Cromwell, CT
Great ice cream, they even have sugar free ice cream too. There is a variety flavors to choose from and there is seating... inside. There is plenty of parking, there are tables and chairs in the back of the parking lot to sit down and enjoy your icecream. Read more
Got a brownie sundae. Super affordable at only 6 dollars. Mint oreo was good, salted caramel was better, and the peanut butter... swirl flavor was ok, had a giant piece of frozen peanut butter in it. The brownie was ok too. The servers were very polite. Read more
Best ice cream ever, the place is spotless, easy to find. Most of all the employees are friendly, always smiling, polite and... happy. The employees actually thank you for your business that goes a long way in my book.. Great experience..thank you all forbeing so awesome. Read more
Ice cream was absolutely amazing but the customer service is quite under par. My husband ordered his ice cream in a waffle cone... with two toppings and when the girl handed his ice cream out it was in a bowl, no cone. We said oh we ordered that in awaffle cone and she just gave us a look with a snippy response. No ?Im sorry your order wasnt right", or "oh heres the extracharge from the cone you didnt get"... nothing. She said the toppings could not be added because of the cone. Its sad since thatice cream was very good but I don?t think we will be returning. Read more
Ice cream was great! However, the people working here are NOT very friendly. I feel like going out for ice cream should be a fun... experience. I don't get that fun vibe here. I'll come back because the ice cream is delicious. Just knowing in my mind thatsnippy people will hand it to me like I did something wrong. Read more
The person who took care of me was nice but the ice cream not so. The flavor I wanted was coconut and because I come from the... Caribbean I now very well what it suppose to taste like. It was way far from that taste. More like vanilla with coconut flakes.Sadly and the price was not cheap either. I don?t know about the other flavors but if what you are looking for is coconut thisis not the place to go. Read more
We were on a day trip and wound down our day by backtracking a little for Tall Man's Ice cream. I am on the hunt for all the... best homemade and handmade ice cream in CT. So far, Tall Man's is in my top 5. FOOD I purchased the hot fudge sundae withwhipped cream, candied walnuts and black cherry vanilla ice cream. The cherries in the ice cream were huge and not supersweet....flavorful. I had a piece of a cherry in every bite. (Sundae had no fixed price: $6.90) Steve had the salted caramel.(Small cone $4.65) Good stuff. STAFF VERY kind...they checked the ingredients of the candied nuts for a gluten allergy noticefor me! I cannot stress enough how this is a kindness for Celiac sufferers (especially for kids!) I feel like a businessowner/staff member who takes a moment to make the customer feel a little be safer in their food choices really must be proud oftheir work. ATMOSPHERE Because this was a chilly and breezy drab March day, it was not crowded, of course. However, there was acouple there when we arrived, one couple just left and another pulled in after us. There is a well landscaped seating area awayfrom the building. Super clean lot and grounds. I bet this gets wicked busy in the summer. It is also on a main road....not hardto find. Generous parking. Very enjoyable experience, delicious ice cream that hit the spot! TOTALLY RECOMMENDED for the entirefamily. Read more
Many delicious options...it's my new favorite ice cream place. Frequently open when other ice cream places have closed for the... season Read more