Reviews for Gator's Tavern in Cortland, NY
Pizza is okay and the wings were not crispy at all. The fries were the worst fries I ever had in my life. They weren't even... crispy or cooked, they were still hard alittle still, it felt like he cooked it in a pan. The Pizza crust was still doughy andit looked like they bought it from a grocery store that's pre-made. Frozen pizza was better then this pizza. I wouldn'trecommend this place for food at all. Read more
Great litte place for food and drinks. Great service.
First time here. Stuffed bread sticks and pizza are to die for Definitely will be back
Was good but this totally a local town bar and we were total strangers but hell had a good time.
We had a party of 9 and needed a last minute place to eat after a full day of moving 2 freshmen into their dorms and needing to... get them back for a meeting, we googled and found Gators. The place had a rough exterior to it, BUT the ole saying don'tjudge... Inside the bar area looked awesome and you had a Cheers feeling as the wait staff took care of us very well. Ourwings were a little late getting to the table but the owner took care of us apologizing (unnecessarily)they were short staff, acommon issue in most places, but still manged to put smiles on the 9 of our faces. Definitely a place to have a drink and aburger. Looking forward to going again. Read more
One of my favorite places to eat. The pizza and wings are the best. The management is incredible. Great place for a casual... environment and a bite to eat...and drinks of course ???? Read more
First time here, and we will be back! We got a calzone (huge, well filled, and perfectly cooked), and a cheeseburger sub with... fries (delicious!). Fair prices as well. 5? Read more
Pizza is fantastic! Burgers are generous! Prices good. Bartenders are hard-working and fun! Great outdoor seating! Highly... recommend! Owner truly cares about customers! Read more