Reviews for Day One Pizza in Columbus, WI
It?s 2022, and to order Day One Pizza, you have to download their menu in PDF format. Phone numbers are not even ?clickable??so,... turn your clocks back to circa 1991. Tried going through the process this evening, and halfway through, I figured it was justeasier to order James Street. Read more
This was my first time at day one pizza, andI was incredibly impressed with the kindness I was shown. They have the best... breadsticks I have ever had!! We will definitely be back soon!! Read more
I've always loved the place. The last 20 years it's been the best pizza in the area and the owner is so kind and fun to talk to!
Just had the most delightful experience I've ever had ordering a pizza. David was amazing and informative. He was incredibly... helpful and positive. Looking forward to ordering again. Read more
I have placed orders with them for years. They overcharge for delivery and skimp on toppings, but they are the only pizza place... to deliver to Fall River. Unfortunately they now won?t answer their phones. Would be nice if they took orders online but I guessthey can?t afford that either. Very disappointed and dissatisfied. Read more
We love this place. The pizza is perfect every time and we like the breadsticks and cinnamon sticks so much that sometimes we... order just those for pickup when we're having pasta or frozen pizzas for dinner. Pro tip: the cinnamon sticks are greatreheated for breakfast the next morning. Pandemic note: this place takes the pandemic seriously and they do a great job ofmaintaining safety, pay over the phone and pick up at the counter without ever getting close to anyone. The dining room isclosed for now but this is really a takeout/delivery kind of place anyway. The only downside is there is no online ordering andsometimes we have to call two or three times to get through on a busy night. Read more
Pizza and bread appetizers are decent. I've yet to try the salad due to the fact that the chicken isn't very good. They seem to... lack any kind of customer service on their phones. It's not that they're rude, but they lack a presence and fail to developrapport. As an example, I placed an order for a pizza and the gentleman on the phone went silent and then asked me if I wasstill there. He didn't confirm the order and was waiting for me to direct the conversation. Additionally, every time I order fordelivery they move to get off the call and I have to interrupt them to request to pay by card. Good service would warrant themasking how one will be paying for the order (e.g. "and will that be cash or card today"?). A please and thank you would go along way too. This is so off putting that I'd gladly order from another business for delivery if they had any competition inColumbus. Read more
My first review was five stars.. The pizza is good, however, Friday night here at 6pm at time of post and have been calling for... 40 minutes. 22 calls, no answer. Guess it?s a one line shop. Read more