Reviews for The Old Mohawk in Columbus, OH
Great local pub holding true to its roots. Staff was fun and friendly. Great menu selection for small and large bites. You need... to try the turtle soup. It does not disappoint. Read more
Turtle soup was fun to try, since I've never had it. The turkey burger and mushroom spinach quesadilla were great! Also... pictured: the half Mother Mohawk and half reuben sandwiches with bowls of turtle soup. Read more
Amazing food at a great price. They were very busy the day we stopped in but we were seated within minutes. The staff was great.
Longtime local bar/restaurant. Great bourbon selection and lots of hometown menu options. Tried the turtle soup and meatloaf... dinner. Both excellent options. The chocolate cake for dessert was the best. Read more
Our dinner at old Mohawk left a lot to be desired. This was the first true date night for my husband and I in a very long time... and it was pretty disappointing. The service at old Mohawk gets 5 stars. However, the food would be a 2 at best. The spinach dipappetizer was cold, soupy and lacked flavor. My husbands burger came out as pictured. The top bun was put in a pool of themyoglobin from the burger which was quite nasty. I got the meatloaf dinner and it was not good at all. The meatloaf was dry andthe mashed potatoes were lumpy. It was on par with the meatloaf lunch you?d be served in grade school. The macaroni and cheese(pictured) had over cooked bread crumbs on the top and was runny as well. Not much different in flavor than what you wouldexpect from a stoffers meal. I had high hopes for the old Mohawk but sadly this place missed the mark. Read more
Good casual spot to get some food or a drink or both. You can tell the place has some history and is definitely an old building... that gives it character. Has a fun pub type atmosphere and the food is decent. Prices are reasonable and the service was promptand polite. I'd come back here again in the future. Read more
We had a wonderful dinner last night at The Old Mohawk! Much of the delight was due to our server Taylor! She was great in every... way a server should be! A real pleasure! I had the Meatloaf with mashed potatoes and gravy and green beans was delicious and aMohawk tradition. The beans were so good! My wife had a Reuben sandwich with French onion soup which she loved. The sandwich wasloaded with meat! Do not leave here without desert! My favorite was the Salted caramel lava cake. So good! Read more
So when we first arrived there was a waitress that was super rude. The bartender however redeemed my first impression by being... super nice. We decided to stay and so glad we did.. Once seated our waitress (a different young lady with a cool tattoo on herarm) Was amazing! My friend ordered turtle soup, I wasn't that adventurous but she said it was so good. I ordered the fishand chips and the fish was cooked to perfection. The cauliflower and the crab balls (can't remember the name) were so freakinggood. Glad that we stayed despite our first not so great welcome. We visited Old Mohawk on Saturday, 10/22/22 around 7:30 PM. Read more