Reviews for Carfagna's Ristorante in Columbus, OH
Carfagna's has some of the best Italian food I have tried around Columbus to date. Our waiter, Jeffro, was an absolute delight... and I am thankful that he made our first visit to this restaurant so memorable. Service was quick. The food was incredible ? Iam eager to visit again and try a new menu item! Read more
Beautiful store and restaurant! The bar area is huge yet comfortable, staff are very kind and courteous. Options to sit on... outdoor patio, indoor "patio", and restaurant as well. The bartender was very helpful with selecting wine and the pizza wasdelicious! Read more
This restaurant shares the building with with it's Italian deli supermarket Which is very cool. The food was excellent, And the... atmosphere is great. It was very busy the night we were there but they had multiple people waiting on us So service was verygood. Highly recommend this Italian restaurant! Read more
This is a full-service establishment. It has everything: restaurant, deli, bakery, hot food bar, coffee bar and wine shop. The... food is delicious! The service is outstanding and the staff is knowledgeable and friendly. Bring your 'mad money' and get somepistachio biscotti or mezzaluna ravioli for the freezer and don't forget the homemade sauce! It's a taste of home. Read more
Loved it! We came here after a golf lesson and had a great time. The food was awesome and the service was so fast. And the... wine selection was amazing. After lunch we did a wine tasting and met new friends. We will definitely be back! I had thegrouper- it was delicious. Read more
I had a chance to stop by for a after work outing and boy was I amazed. The smoked cocktail was delicious and the food was very... different and delightful. I also like the liquor store selection and the fun ice cubes. I will be back for sure! Read more
As a patron of the original Carfagna's Italian Market off Dublin-Granville Road, the new Polaris establishment illuminates what... the owner's must have always had in mind but have been unable to bring to fruition given the original stores limited footprint.Even though the original store is smaller, with tight aisles packed with loads of signature and unique goods - the stores closequarters lends to a special experience where you may be tenth in line, elbow to elbow with other Carfagna's patrons, but theemployees behind the counter make quick work and are super friendly and engaging at every step of the way. The new locationgives you much, much more space whilst grocery shopping for those signature and unique items, providing you more than just elbowroom. The Polaris location also offers a very large liquor store with a plethora of spirits and wines. Lastly, the newrestaurant takes up a substantial portion of the facility, with an incredible bar area and plenty of tables to handle any rushPolaris can throw at it. The menu contains pretty much every Italian dish you would expect, including some nice lunch mix/matchcombos (like salad or soup and half a sandwich). The prices are absolutely reasonable and in line with the quality and portions- my only qualm was the wait time while dining. The staff was very attentive; however, they were short staffed in the front andit took some time getting my order in and check received/cashed. I am still giving 5 stars as this is the first week opening andthey are probably tightening these processes up - I will be back and will update accordingly! Read more
Staff was friendly and attentive. Food was so-so. My chicken marsala was over-breaded and overcooked; it was tough. My wife's... veal parmesan was also very overcooked and tough. The highlight 9f.dinner, though, was the plate my entree was served on. Itrocked and turned on it's own. I had to try to hold it to keep it from spinning while sawing my chicken. Every bite to ked theplate. Unacceptable. Do better. Read more