Reviews for Potbelly in Columbus, OH
We've visited Potbelly multiple times, we always enjoy the food. The loaded potato soup is delicious! It's a great value, and... great food, cool atmosphere! Read more
Out of 3 sandwiches we ordered, two were incorrect. One had onions although we verified we didn't have onions in the order. We... paid for bacon in another and it wasn't on the sandwich. The store wasn't busy, and the order was done at least 5 minutes beforethe scheduled pickup time. There was no option in the app or confirmation email to report a problem with the order. Read more
I love their sandwiches. I always get a skinny roast beef and turkey with provolone cheese, mustard, oil and Italian seasoning... with a side of pepper. They also have great cookies! It?s a nice dine in area as well(always clean). The staff is superfriendly. Read more
Incredibly disappointing! They actually charge $2.49 for one slice of cheddar cheese! And it's disgusting that they hand tore... that one slice. How about shredded cheese like every other restaurant?! Read more
Stumbled upon this place via GrubHub. Sounded good, ordered it, and man, it was not good, but great!! Also, I've never ordered a... side of Mac that makes me want to come back. This is THE sandwich spot in Columbus, period. Read more
It was a great sandwich! I had the Italian and it was delightfully flavoful. Definitely make sure to get the hot peppers on the... side to control the heat. And the place had a interesting feeling, I love the tin ceiling! Read more
I don?t know if it was me or the day i ordered sandwiches from this place. Beef and Mediterranean chicken sandwich were just too... dry. The whole experience of potbelly sandwiches i had in chicago made me order from here, but this turned out to be a drag. Iam not going to order anything from here again. Usually the sandwiches are fresh and warm, not sure what happened when they mademine, it felt worse than a subway sandwich.Not dissing subway at all here, but usually potbelly is more premium than subway iswhat i have felt. Regardless, the ambience and the sitting arrangements at this location were clean and quiet spacious. Theplace was well lit and a good location to be at in polaris. Read more
The employees at this location are always the worst. Horrible attitudes. Never make the sandwiches right. I?ve been to this... specific location three times and every time was worse then the last. They need to hire new people. Read more