Reviews for Papa Giorgios in Columbus, OH
I live two counties away and every time I within 5 miles of Papa Giorgio's I make it a point to stop. Wonderful NY style pizza,... this visit I brought a buddy and now he's hooked too. Great pizza! The atmosphere question is pretty funny, it's a hole in thewall pizza shop with extremely limited space so we appreciate the few tables they have since it appears 95% of their business istakeout. Read more
The pizzas were great. The perfecto is my favorite so far. There are still plenty that I haven't tried. The thin dough reminds... me of a traditional Italian pizza. Very nostalgic considering I lived in Italy for 4 years. Great service as well. Everythingwas ready in a timely manner. Delizioso! Read more
Worth checking out. Very good pizza. Got a pepperoni, mushroom, and sausage. A little on the greasy side but given the... toppings I expected it. Will try the house favorite next time. It's on our list of pizza places to order from for now on.Reheated well next day too. Read more
Very good food. We decided to stop in and eat since we were going downtown for a concert. They have a couple of tables inside.... Mostly a carry out place. We wanted the family special listed on the menu section of their Google Maps information. That listingis wrong. That was a grand opening special. Their current special is a large two item pizza, spaghetti and meatballs, cheesybread and two butter garlic rolls for$27.99. That was a lot of food and and it was all really good. The pizza crust and saucewere fantastic. The toppings were high quality. The spaghetti and meatballs were excellent. Highly recommend this place! Theyare considering opening another place on the north end. That's were I live and I will absolutely be a regular customer if theydo. Read more
Ordered a Supreme without olives and was pleased. East coast style thin crust pie with a bit of flop to it but comes together... nicely. Great sauce and good service. Solid game day choice. Read more
Wow the house favorite pizza is so good! I use to go to a small place in my hometown called Pizza Chef and order a pizza just... like the house favorite. I?m so happy I discovered this place and will be ordering from here more often. Read more
Really good pizza. I?d say one of the best NY style pizzas in Columbus. I?ll definitely be coming back.
If you are from the NY NJ ao and you are seriously missing the pizza (like I was until 2 weeks ago) this is your slice ???? of... home. Don't think. Just do it and be happy you did. It's been too many years since I've had this quality pizza. Please eat morefor me since I'm already full. BEST pizza in Ohio!!! Read more