Reviews for Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus in Columbus, OH
When Brenz does it right there is no better pizza in Columbus but lately the inconsistencies in pizza have been profound. The... last one I received was soggy and undercooked. Paying nearly 30 dollars and leaving a tip to have to cook my pizza in the airfryer and it still have an off taste. The time before that it was missing the toppings and the guy in the back asked "since whendid it come with that. The cashier responded ALWAYS" Whatever section the dark-haired guy with the mustache is in, suffers whenhe's working please retrain him. Last time he couldn't even hear the cashier because he had his headphones in. Read more
Not sure what all the fuss is a bout, it's very below average pizza IMO, sauce it tasty but overwelmingly sweet and you tire of... it quickly. Toppings are very cheap looking and tasting (it's all very clearly prepackaged and not fresh at all), it's fine ifyou need a bite but by no way exceptional, I would not order again. Read more
Such an amazing business who supports our healthcare workers endlessly!! We in turn support this local business!! Adam has made... our night once again!! Not only is he funny, he made sure our orders were correct, and made sure we got cookies to keep us goingall night!! Thank you Brenz Pizza for keeping Labor & Delivery nurses nourished with our leaning tower of ????!! ???????? Read more
Really nice atmosphere inside. Very yummy pizza, great crust.
Visiting from Norwalk for an event and a birthday. We did a Google search and this place seemed to have the best looking pizza... and wings. We hoped it tasted well and placed the order! The 5 of us were amazed by the flavors of the pizza and wings; thepizza was beautifully made just like the photos online. Put the order in for pickup and it was done at the time they said itwould be! Read more
I would love to try this place but every time I go they are closed, even though Google and their website say they are open.... Also, their website and Google show a coca-cola machine, but the machine is for Pepsi. I?m here at 7:16 on a Monday night andthey are closed with the lights off and no sign in the window. The pizza looks tasty on their website but how am I supposed totrust that that?s actually what their pizza looks like if the rest of their website/Google is wrong? Edit: to the owner, thankyou for your response. I appreciate that there is absolutely a shortage of staff right now but if you just put a sign on thedoor and made your hours clearer on Google maps (as well as not saying ?OPEN NOW? in big letters on your site) then I thinkeveryone would understand. I am looking forward to trying your restaurant when I can and will update my rating accordingly atthat time. Read more
Excellent pizza, closer to traditional style than Ohio/Midwest style even though the pizzas are square cut. It's basically a... nice Ohio/Traditional hybrid. Brenz offers a variety of unique pizzas and a ton of different toppings. Stopped in on 02/22 andordered a 12" Spinach Artichoke, a 16" Rustic, Bread sticks with Cheese, 5 bone in mild wings, and a Meatball sub. All of thatwas $64 so it was a little pricey, but after trying a bit of everything I can definitely say it was worth it. Their ingredientsare quite fresh and they stack the pizza with toppings. Bread sticks made using dough from scratch and topped with goldencrisped cheese, the sub was on a homemade bun with homemade meatballs, and they also make their own ranch - which is pretty goodbut not as good as Tommy's or Hounddogs' ranch. Overall it's a terrific alternative to the abundance of Ohio/Midwest stylepizzas in Columbus. Personally I'd give a Brenz a 4.8 overall, with the price being the only drawback. Since Google doesn'tallow decimal reviews I rounded up to a 5. Read more
By far one of the best, if not flat out the best pizza I have ever tried! It's like the old style pizza shops of the past, hand... made and cooked in a brick oven. The crust is crisp, had a small amount of crust around the outside of the pizza, has a greatsauce, and the toppings taste so fresh and cooked just right. I have found my new favorite pizza shop! I am stuffed, and I wantto order another one it tasted so good! Give them a try, you won't be disappointed! Read more