Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Columbus, IN
This store has an amazing staff. They are friendly and energetic. The atmosphere is positive every time I order. The pizza is... always good. This is our favorite pizza place! Read more
Papa Johns is alright overall but this store in particular will never see a dime from me again. Go to a different Papa Johns.
Three stars because it definitely is just one of those pizzas you eat when you just have to eat something and that's all there... is but it does the job. Today however I'm feeling slightly diarrhea ish Read more
Bad management. I called in a pizza order. Told the guy i had a coupon. Got to the place and manager and cashier said we don,t... take coupons unless you order online. Even though the coupon did not say online order. I left the pizza there and they had noproblem with that so lose lose situation. Read more
Staff is always so friendly! Food is always on point. Always done quickly and when I have it delivered it?s delivered very... quickly as well. Not had a bad experience here. And I eat it a lot haha All good experiences! Read more
My pizza had so much sauce on it that all my toppings slid off when I picked up a slice. My pizza also was half cut I had to... recut it just to eat it. Now typically this papa johns is REALLY good especially compared to the one in eastbrook plaza which isin my delivery zone so I ordered carry out so I could specifically go to this location. Maybe just a bad night for them. I?llalso add I?m sure if I had asked they?d have remade it but I didn?t ask. As this is truly the first time my orders been messedup at this location. I order from here all the time. All my good experiences make up for my ONE bad experience. Read more
Amazing pizza place that our family has ordered from for years. They are always consistent with how the pizza is made, resulting... in not one bad experience. I recommend never getting the plain original crust, as it is probably the worst crust I've had on apizza. Stuffed crust and parmesan cheese are both very good options. Read more
Pizza is barely cooked every time we order. The toppings, cheese, and all will slide right off on the first bite. Only reason we... still order is because they are the only place that will deliver to our address. Read more