Reviews for Chicago's Pizza in Columbus, IN
Went for the lunch buffet with some coworkers. Everything was hot n fresh on the bar. Salad bar was clean and well maintained.... Pizza was delicious! Had any kind of pizza that you could want!! Was really impressed that they have the jalapeño nacho cheeseon the bar as well!!!! Awesome! I gave 3 stars for atmosphere only cuz they were playing Fox news on the tv and there was alarger party of people across from us talking politics rather loudly. But that is NOT Chicagos fault. Just made it hard to havea conversation with our table. Read more
Best deep dish I?ve ever had in my life
Very good pizza and pasta! Our server was friendly and doing her best on a very busy night. The restaurant is very clean and... well maintained. Also a great partner to local places with their fundraising opportunities. Very accommodating for a book clubas well. Read more
I'd love to give this place 5 stars because the food is amazing and it's incredibly clean. We've come 3 times in the last 2... weeks and always tipped well except for tonight because the same thing has been an issue all 3x now. We originally thought maybeshe was having a bad night the first time but now 3 separate times the older blonde woman working the carry out register hasbeen exceptionally rude. I've always smiled at her, used manners, and this last time commented on how excited we were to find aChicago's in Columbus just for her to thrust the receipt at me. And tell me to sign it all with a nasty look on her face and arude tone then immediately walk away. I'm usually the type of person to leave a 40-50% tip especially on carry out because Iknow most people don't tip them but I just can't justify that anymore here with how she's treated us. If she hates her job somuch she feels the need to take it out on customers who are kind to her she needs to find somewhere else to work not in customerservice. This also happened at 6pm, 7pm, and 645pm no where near closing. I was always quick to decide what to order and keptthings simple and the same order each time. We aren't sure if we're going to come back at this point or just try to findsomewhere else. Read more
I think this is the best pizza in town. It has quality toppings and you can get a one trip salad bar at a bargain. The service... is always excellent. The atmosphere in cleanliness is always a+ plus Read more
Should not be allowed to include Chicago in the name. The deep dish is pretty much a cheaper ingredient version of Pizza Hut. I... think Little Ceaser?s makes a better deep dish (no joke). Absolutely nothing like a Chicago style deep dish pie. Sure hope theirthin or traditional pizza is good. The deep dish certainly is not. Read more
Disappointing. This is the large "Magnificent Mile"... their version of a supreme. Mostly it was cheese and sauce with a few... finely chopped toppings. The flavor was decent but, for the price and the amount of toppings you get, it's really not worth it. I would say it fell short of Magnificent. Read more
This place is awesome! The buffet is delicious, but only lasts 11-1:30. Everything is just so good! Bread sticks, cheese sauce,... cheese bread, pizza, salad... it's all so dang good! Prices went up after covid, but also now includes your drink in the buffetprice. I make it a point to come here every time I'm in town, which sadly isn't often. But this place is great! Read more