Reviews for By The Fire Pizza & Bar in Columbia, SC

Incredibly disappointing across the board- placed order @ 5:40- received text messages @ 6:09 that my order was ready..literally... was pulling up to the door @ 6:10 only to be told that the order wasn't ready and it would be a few more minutes.. 6:20 I goback in and I'm told the kitchen got backed up it would be another 5-10 minutes and I show the young lady the text message fromthe restaurant saying my order was ready... she told me they didn't send that text the online ordering system (Slice) sent it.My question is who told Slice it was ready? so almost an hour after I placed my order it was "ready".. got home and Dear God...Half the pizza was inedible because the dough was uncooked, the cheesesticks only had cheese on 5 of the middle sticks, thetoppings on the large pizza we got were lightly distributed and spotty and did not extend past the center of the pizza, nocheese pull what-so-ever- and the personal supreme @ $13.95 had about 1 bite of thinly layered toppings per slice. What I foundmost off putting was the amount of raw, uneven cooked dough when the pizza was turned over, the lack of cheese on the "cheesebread", and the fact that we waited almost an additional 30 minutes and ended up throwing over half our order away. Our totalfor 1 large 2 topping, 1 personal supreme and 1 order of cheese bread was $46.92. Save yourself the dollars and go see Zorba's,Marco's, Pizza Hut or the Papa.... #thisaintit Read more

Damn! This place was so good! When we walked in we were greeted by Darian, she was so kind. The beer was cold and the atmosphere... was super chill. We ordered a large pep for our son and wings which were 99 cents each on Wednesdays. The Gyro was bomb!!! Willdefinitely be back for more! Read more

So my neighbor friends and I like to try new places and we heard this place was good. We ordered 2 different pizza?s, a gyro and... the steak and cheese. It was all delicious, the staff was friendly, the service was great and the place is spotless. They evenhad light jazz music playing that added a special touch. I highly recommend this little gem! Read more

First off I have to shout out the owner. She was fantastic! She played hostess, waitress and chef with a shortage of workers.... Short staffed and the food still came out fabulous. The side salad is a generous portion and all the veggies were crisp. Myhusband and I shared a sausage pizza, it was very good. The crust was crispy, the sausage fresh ground, and the sauce remindedme of home (NJ). If you?re craving some good ole NY/NJ pizza this is a great spot to go to. Highly recommend. Please like andshare below. Read more

Pizza and cheese bread are very good. Great service as well for my take out order. Dining room looks nice, looking forward to... dining in soon Read more

My husband and I ordered a 14? supreme pizza (no mushroom, no black olives, add banana peppers on 1/2, add jalapeños on 1/2)... and 6 ct hot Buffalo wings for pick up. When my husband arrived they politely greeted him and finished preparing our order. Thepizza was very good - nice soft crust, good ratio for sauce and toppings, and great size slices. The wings were also very good -large, cooked very well, and generously sauced. Overall we were very happy and will definitely be ordering again. Great customerservice, yummy food, and reasonable prices. Read more

Decent looking place. Sat us, let us order drinks, and THEN told us they had no pizza dough to make pizzas. Told us to come back... and try them out. Maybe a free drink or an appetizer would have enticed us to do so.. or.. letting us before seating us andgetting drinks. Response to owner- the review is about being sat and served drinks and then being told you are out ofdough. That?s bad customer service. That?s why there?s a bad review. Read more

I've been on the lookout for a good pizza place for years. Stopped by during my lunch hour to grab a pie and had a beer while my... pizza baked. Bret was super friendly and the bar is very nice. Pizza is fantastic and can't wait to bring my family by soon.Check this place out guys! Read more