Reviews for Anderson's Pizza in Columbia, KY
They recently got new management for like the 3rd time in the past couple years. It slowly got worse but there has been new... management for almost a month now and idk if it has gotten better. We had takeout for a fundraiser and it was nothing specialand I think Pizza Hut is better. The last management didn?t even give them the fundraiser money. Read more
BEWARE- Fri 9/2/22 8:50pm looking to get a bite to eat and most places listed online close at 9pm. Anderson's Pizza website... indicates open till 11pm so we drive over. Lot's of cars there but open sign turned off. Walk up to the door of the restaurantand says Fri hours open till 11pm. Go inside and waitress while polite apologizes the kitchen just closed. I said "I don'tunderstand, your hours on the door & online say open till 11pm". She replies "That's the bar, not restaurant" (Bar in separatebut connected part of building) I asked in discouraged tone, "Well do you sell any bar food?" She goes to speak with very tallyoung man & returns apologetically replying "No". So we leave. Here's a pizza dive that won't advertise truthfully and afterseeing other reviews online the last few months, doesn't seem to care about bad customer service or addressing existingproblems. So if you are looking for slow to bad service & bad food, you have found them both here. Otherwise, go anywhere else.BEWARE Read more
Really rude staff. We told her the ski sauce on the wings was spicy and she rolled her eyes. If you need to feed your one night... stand I suggest there. That's about the equivalence of the place. Very dirty im surprised we didn't see bugs. How long does ittake to make baked spaghetti. I believe it's been almost 30min now. Come on I see food going out of the kitchen but of coursenot. 40min later. Nope never coming back here. Read more
Don't waste your time or money going to Anderson's Pizzeria in Columbia, KY. The hand-tossed crust is as thin as thin crust at... most pizza places. The BBQ chicken pizza barely had any BBQ sauce, the chicken had no flavor, and trying to eat the pizza waslike chewing wads of cheese. The chicken bacon ranch pizza tasted like greasy garlic. One bite immediately made me sick at mystomach. The waitress was apologetic, but whoever came out from the kitchen was not friendly, understanding, or apologetic; shewas just plain rude. She said she couldn't comp the pizza because it was a specialty pizza. She gave me a generous 50% discount(read the sarcasm here). I suppose that's going above and beyond to make a customer happy. ???? She even asked if I'd ever hadthat type pizza before. I've had pizza from several establishments across the United States; yes, including this type pizza soknow what it's supposed to taste like. Save yourself the agony; just go somewhere else. Read more
Every bite was a squirt of grease. Horrible experience. Toppings weren't even over the whole pie. Definitely not going again!
Fantastic food at a great price! We got delivery and ordered the "Columbia Giant" and giant is a very accurate description! Also... ordered a calzone and the loaded nachos. Everything was fantastic! We have a family of 7 and to have leftovers is a rarity!Quality and quantity for sure! Read more
We were in town for the day visiting and decided to stop in. My husband found this place on a google search. We like to try all... the local pizza restaurants in all the city's we travel too. Friendly customer service (sadly that is hard to find anymore),great price and delicious food. By far the best we've had in awhile. I will add that my husband has a culinary degree and is achef so he can be a harsh critic . We will definitely be back. Read more
I ordered a crown apple on rocks, short glass. I got coke and crown I guess.. when I asked what it was the male bartender had... attitude and said " it's what you ordered" I said , " no I ordered a crown apple on rocks, short glass... He walked away cussingme.. I wouldn't recommend dealing with him.. other than that it was a great place to sit back a relax with some good karaoke????... Read more