Reviews for Cold Spring Pizza in Cold Spring, NY
Mediocre pizza.. but it?s the cheaper food options in this town so we stuck to it. We got the plain pizza so maybe that?s why we... thought it was underwhelming. At first glance, the pizza is oily and flat. It tastes like it looks. Read more
Regular pizza, nothing special. One of the guys behind the counter kept touching his lip area while serving pizza. Gross.
The pizza here is so DELISH! I stop by after I go kayaking and get a slice of their grandma pizza - highly recommend! Quite... frankly, I'm not sure anymore if I go to Cold Spring for the kayaking or the pizza - either way, it's a win-win! Special thankyou to Tom who confirmed tonight that someone found my missing turquoise wireless earbuds on their ATM machine. (Can't wait toretrieve them). Great group of guys working here and delicious pizza. Highly recommend if you're in the neighborhood! Read more
If you?re looking for a GOOD NY slice out in this area, this is your place. Heard they?re from the BX originally and they don?t... disappoint Read more
Good old pizza place in Cold Spring. Following our five and half hours hike up the Breakneck Ridge, amongst other loops, my... friend and I were in need of a quick refuel before we catch the train back to NYC. Pizza seemed like the perfect food to have.The store is a 7-minute walk from the Cold Spring Metro North Station. The place has a classic design from the window, to themenu panel and seats inside. They have quite a vast amount of food choices too! Anything from pizza, seafood spaghetti, to softserved ice cream! I got the chicken, bacon, and chipotle sauce pizza. My friend got his with fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, andwhat seems to be thinly sliced sausages. On top of it, we got the classic cheese pizza to share. The total came to $12 for 3pizzas. Not sure if it applies now, but if you pay cash you can get a 3% discount, according to a sign written on the cashregister. There is a seating area outside of the store. There is no indoor dining as of now yet due to the coronavirus. Thepizzas were great! Thin crusts with the right amount of sauce and cheese so the bread remained crisp. They were flavorful yetnot overwhelming. The only thing that I wasn't too crazy about was, as is expected with the majority of pizzas, there were alittle bit of extra grease, which probably came from the bacon and cheese. Regardless they were still great pizzas! We savouredeach bite that it only left us with just enough time to walk back and catch the train. Will definitely get more the next time wereturn. Read more
Very greasy pizza and I have no idea why the reviews are so great. I took the spicy chicken and barbecue chicken sandwiches.... Barbecue was overly sweet and didn't taste good at all. I personally love barbecue so I took pork barbecue pizza too. Honestly,it was worse. Although the staff was very polite and welcoming. Read more
Excellent NYC Pizza! This place is really good and I'm very picky with Italian food(I grew up in Queens). The regular slice is... good. The Sicilian is awesome. It's perfect. Try a slice and you'll be hooked. I take home a whole Sicilian pie everytimeI'm there. Read more
The cheese pizza was good but the tables were dirty along with the bathroom. At 5pm not many choices to eat as everything starts... to close down. Read more