Reviews for Rudy’s Ristorante & Pizzeria in Closter, NJ

A stocky guy at the cash register. How should I say, he touches money then he grabs a bunch of cheese and puts on a slice. And... then he touches money again. And then he grabs another slice and puts it to the oven. All these things happened without washingnor sanitizing his hands after dealing with cash. For real? Dirtiest pizza restaurant worker ever. Read more

Phenomenal! I had the Sunday pasta gravy and it reminded me of my Mom's when I was younger. My wife had grilled chicken over... salad and my daughter had the chicken marsala. Everything was terrific. Can't wait to go back!! Read more

I love Rudy's and everything I've ever had was amazing! My last meal was awful! I had a Chicken Caesar Salad, the lettuce was... wilted and it had no taste I ended up throwing it away and a large Margherita Pizza which was already luke warm when I got thereand it had no taste! I'm so disappointed because I've eaten from here several times! Read more

This place has great tasting pizza! Delicious cheesy goodness. Staff are also friendly and nice. Fast service in case you?re in... a time crunch. I got their mushroom pizza. They have a small bar too in case you want something fancy to go along with thepizza. ???? + ???? = ???? Read more

Best pizza on the East Coast!! **Update 09/05/2020 Ate here today inside when they finally opened the indoor dinning. The... tables were empty except for a sign to download the menu. Great drink selection including Joes Tea. Pizza and wings were bothsuper delicious!! Eating inside again finnally!!!! **Update 08/14/2018 Ate here a few times during the stupid lockdowns of2020. They now have outdoor seating under umbrella tables. The food was delicious as always. Delicious pizza as always! Diningroom super clean. Ample free parking. Great service, great prices, super fast and one of the best pizzas in NJ and the entireUSA!! Read more

What a wonderful little gem of a restaurant. I needed to run out and get some quick quality dinner before a late night meeting... and I was not disappointed by Rudy?s. The deceiving front lead to back into a well lit area with nice updated Decor. The waitstaff was friendly and efficient. I got the mama Mia platter and it was absolutely delicious. I will absolutely go back but thistime I think I may try a pizza because the front of the restaurant had my mouthwatering when I walked in Read more

Had a good dining experience here. The two of us shared the nights special - Trio of veal, shrimp and chicken parmigiana with... ziti and the special house salad. All great. Super tasty red sauce. Love their italian bread too. Even though splitting, it wasmore than we could eat and took some home. The red Sangria was the best we ever had. Jamie was our server and did a bang up job.She's efficient friendly and attentive as was all the staff we came across. Bathrooms were spotless. We'll have to come back Read more

I spent few times around eating Italian food in NYC and NJ and Rudy's it's the most authentic, I was feeling like home and it's... very important! The Pizza it's unbelievable! And the quality of the food it's great, that's what make this place THE BEST! Read more