Reviews for Izzy's in Madisonville, OH
There is no longer any Izzy's locations near me. While in Southern Ohio, me and a friend found this location on our way back... home. Kyli was our server. She and the other staff on duty did a wonderful job with our orders. Both my friend and I had CornBeef sandwiches and potato cakes for inside dining. Since we knew it would be sometime before we made it back to an Izzy's wealso ordered "deconstructed" Reubens to go. The kitchen staff did a wonderful job in packing it to go knowing we would not beeating them right away. The next day, I warmed up my potato cake and put my Reuben together for lunch. Both meals, delicious asalways. Read more
Amazing sandwiches, some of the best I?ve ever had!
I ordered the new Angus Melt sandwich. I was the best roast beef sandwich I've ever had from a restaurant. The meat was... plentiful, tender, seasoned and Tasted like beef. The grilled onions and banana peppers and cheese elevated the sandwich to thenext level. Hopefully this will be a regular item on the menu. Read more
Decent reuben? slightly above average taste but smaller in portions vs value. Potato cake was greasy and bland but the pasta... salad was delish, cold & refreshing! The takeout order was wrong with several of the items. Pro-tip: always check your bagbefore you head out (: Read more
I'd never been here before. The reuben was incredible. Flavorful throughout, moist bread...every bite was delicious. It came... with a potato pancake that was the perfect balance of crispy outside and soft inside with great seasoning. If you don't likereubens, there are plenty of other items to try, and they're probably just as good! Read more
I got a half Reuben and I loved it! I had never actually had a Reuben before but apparently Izzy?s is famous for it so I had to... try it. It was a very delicious sandwich. The potato pancake was also very good. I got chicken noodle soup and it wasn?t thebest, but overall the meal was delicious. I?ll definitely be back. Read more
I have never been here before. It was very good. Stephen was our server. He patiently explained everything perfectly to us. We... had the Ruben and Joe Walters. Out of both of them I loved the Ruben the best. We were given kosher pickles at the table. Read more
I wanted a corn beef sandwich from Izzy. My 9 yr. old grandson was with me and he never had Izzy before. I asked if he could... taste it. She gave him some on a plate. We took a taste and told our waitress it was salty. My grandson didn't like it. Shesuggested I try the corn beef and pastrami thinking it would cut the salty taste my grandson ordered a hamburger. Well sad tosay it did not work. Told her I didn't want it. I would keep the potato cake because I needed something to eat. They took offthe sandwich and charged me for the potato. I asked why since it came with the sandwich - I was told because I didn't send itback. For medical reasons I had to eat something. I was not happy but I paid the bill and left a tip on the table. Read more