Reviews for Pie-Eyed Pizzeria in Chicago, IL
Friendly staff, toppings are great, cheese is ok, crust is not bad, but the sauce unfortunately doesn't hit the spot. I can't... put my finger on it but it's similar to lunchables pizza sauce. Not the worst thing in the world but not my preference. Stillrecommend it for the different styles of pizza. I still have to try their calzones and other food! Read more
I have been enjoying Pie Eyed Pizza since they opened. I love the quality and creativity of the pizza, and the diversity of the... menu. There are lots of great food choices in addition to the ALWAYS AWESOME pizza! The owners also take so much pride inproviding the best quality food and the customer service possible. They operate their business with the utmost integrity !Always support this business! Read more
If you like good real Chicago Pizza this is your place open till 2:00 in the morning on the weekends
Ordered the slices combo which came with a slice of pizza a medium drink and French fries. The slice came to me very lukewarm... and It was very dry tasting. The French fries were hot thin and crispy which was a good thing. It's your little hole in the wall pizza joint for a late night craving. They're open Until 2 AM on the weekends. Read more
Good pizza! Big slice! But I was especially happy with the cheese fries! Very thin, perfectly seasoned, perfect amount of melted... cheese! Best fries I’ve had in a long time! (Also had shrimp and carrot cake, and they were good, too. But those cheesefries!!) Read more
Delicious! Their pizza of the month is always super creative and tasty. If you're looking for a unique, gourmet pizza then this... is the place. The regular offerings are all solid as well- especially love the shrimp. Have ordered for pick up and deliverybefore- foods consistently hot and fresh. The employees are really friendly and service has always been outstanding! Read more
This is some serious deep dish. Took a chance on a random pizza place in chicago, but lets be honest, the odds are high it will... be awesome. Not disappointed one bit. The jalapeno poppers were super cheesy and the pizza, good lord, the sauce was boss. Thetoppings of roast beef and hot Giardiniera was a perfect fit. On a cold, rainy and snowy April day, we took this beast to a baracross the street and got 1000s of compliments. The smell was to die for. Good job guys. Read more
Love this place for late night eats. Sometimes they close early though which is a bummer when I specifically take a car there... for late night eats only to find out they closed an hour and a half before the scheduled time listed on Google and theirwebsite. Makes it tough to plan to go there. Read more