Reviews for Jimmy's Pizza Cafe in Chicago, IL
I really love their garlic knots. Wish the sauce was warm(not cold), it takes from the flavor of the dish. The pizza was... delicious but it got cold quickly due to the ac blowing hard(it was a bit cold outside. Read more
This place is great for laughs with friends, carefree nostalgia, and of course pizza. They have a wide variety of flavors that... go from creamy and subtle to the more strong truffle or bbq. I'm going to get anchovies on mine next time. Garlic knots withmarinara sauce are also good if you want to change up your textures. Chocolate chip cookies are among my faves - overall, thisspot knows how to handle dough. Read more
New York style yummy pizza. You order and pay for your stuff on the counter and find a table to sit on. There is also a pickup... window and pizza by slice option in this spacious pizzeria.LOVED the crust. Read more
Finally a place that has NY style pizza in Chicago. This was the best pizza I've had in a very long time. Living in S. FL for 20... + years, you miss the NY style pizza. Jimmy's hits on the money! Now they have a new location with tables and soon to havealcohol serviced. Can't wait to go back. Read more
If you love NY style pizza and don?t know about a Jimmy?s Pizza Cafe you are not living life. I loved their original location in... Foster but this extra location is spacious, comfortable, clean and fun to hang at. Even the bathrooms are impressive. They haveeven more styles of pie on offer and the quality is EXACTLY the same as the original Jimmy?s. This pizza is fire. If you don?tknow, now you know. Read more
I grew up in this area, back then this was the old Erin Glen Pub in the 80/90s. Me and the neighborhood kids would by a basket... of fries for 50 cents. Since the pub, the restaurant has changed owners and concepts at least five times over the last twodecades. The owners of Jimmy?s Pizza Cafe have the magic touch offering delicious thin crust NY style pizza with uniquecombinations. The combo with ricotta, prosciutto, basil with drizzled honey was phenomenal. I will be back for it! Read more
My roommate and I are so happy Jimmy?s opened the new location! The pizza is still amazing if not better now that we can eat it... in the restaurant. The interior looks great too. Can?t wait to come back over and over for the best pizza in Chicago!! Read more
Pizza was really good, though a bit pricey. The customer service here definitely has a lot of room for improvement. When I... arrived there was no line and I stood right in front of a couple employees at the counter (one I?m pretty sure was the manager)and I wasn?t even acknowledged for over a minute and when I was it was someone from further away that approached me. For anyonelooking for a restaurant manager position, I?d apply here!!!! Only reason I give 4 stars is the pizza was really good. Read more