Reviews for Corey's NYC Bagel Deli in Chicago, IL
I was a regular (2-3 time a week, $30-$40 per order) tipping customer, but the same cashier messed up the order for the third... time. Does the attached image look like there?s bacon, avocado and cream cheese in it. When asked to be refunded, the manageris dumb enough to get in argument over if the terminology of asking to be refunded for the order is equivalent to gettingrefunded for the bagel when the whole order is just one bagel. On top of that he blamed me for not checking the order before Ileave - yeah, I should unwrap the aluminum foil of the bagel and open it up in the shop to peek inside and see if you guys gotit right. I can?t even trust you guys to get this simple thing correct? Needless to say, good way to lose a customer when asimple ?Sorry, we messed up. Let us make it up to you.? would have done. Read more
For a place that labels itself as a NYC bagel spot, I felt that Corey's was very underwhelming. The bagel itself was almost... below average, and for $20 for a lox with cream cheese??? The cream cheese was really the only redeeming quality of thesandwich. Overall, not the worst bagel I've had, but just not for me. Read more
IF YOU ARE FROM NY/NJ THESE BAGELS ARE SOOOOOO TRASH. False advertising, much closer to a Dunkin? Donuts bagel than anything... you?d get in New York. This is their everything bagel with scallion CC. Sad. Read more
This place is fire ???? ???? ???? love the originality of the bagels, the love and atmosphere in the air, how much cream cheese... they put, and Francisco is the man! Read more
We ordered quite a variety of delicious meal bagels for takeout and I might have overdone the amount of roast beef and chives I... crammed into one bagel sandwich (if that is even possible). We also tremendously enjoyed the salmon bagel and will stronglyrecommend both of these to anyone. Read more
Non-Descript building?. The menu and layout is actually confusing. Can?t tell who?s wait or who ordered but also menus... everywhere. Bagel does have a great bite to it! And no need to say ?extra cheese? cause they smear it in on! ???????? Read more
Loved the amount of options available. Great company leadership and friendly family vibe. High quality ingredients and great... flavor. Central location for a quick grab and go bite. Read more
Most overpriced, flavorless bagel sandwich I?ve ever had. If you?re coming here expecting a NYC bagel sandwich, prepare to be... disappointed Read more