Reviews for Anderson's Frozen Custard in Cheektowaga, NY
OMG, fantastic roast beef on wick. Like option of 3 oz or 5 oz sandwich. Best custard ever esp my favorite chocolate vanilla... twist. Wish I still lived in the area so I could enjoy more often. As it is now, gotta get on a plane to get my Anderson's"fix". 5 plus stars ???? Read more
OK, so I've only had the ice cream cake and the big wheels (had to look that up because I grew up on Carvel and they're always... flying saucers to me) but I'm addicted. Almost glad there wasn't a Carvel around for my birthday and we discovered this. Read more
$4.12 for a small custard is highway robbery not to mention $6.95 for a BBQ beef that barely had any meat. Ridiculous.
I absolutely LOVE andersons! Never had better ice cream, their sundaes are delicious, milkshakes are amazing, I really recommend... going here if you haven?t already. Plus they?re really nice there Read more
Great ice cream flavor choices, including plant based options. Highly recommend roast beef sandwich, many choices to make it... your own! Read more
So this place has decided to go cheap. No name everything and eliminating choices off the menu. The no name cola had always been... bad enough now it's monarch brand ketchup. At the prices they are charging for processed roast beef you would think they coulduse higher quality items. Read more
The line for food was fast and efficient, and the food came even faster than I expected. Eating the roast beef on weck brought... back many wonderful childhood memories. The custard was just as creamy and delicious as I thought it would be. If you're in thearea, I will always recommend stopping there. Read more
Very inconsistent, half the time its great but the other half of the time my soft serve is a fluffy mess. This most recent time... I decided to do a float for once and they gave me basically no ice cream in a large cup and told me to fill the soda myself. Notthat I have anything against the filling the soda, but soda is dirt cheap and I shouldnt be getting so little ice cream for5.50. Just not worth trying with this place anymore. Read more