Reviews for Magone Italian Grill & Pizza in Chapel Hill, NC

I saw the other negative review on the 1 star lasagna situation and I?d like to chime in. First off, if you have ONE negative... experience but MANY positive ones with a business, why slam them with such a negative review!? You know how bad that can hurt abusiness!?!! I had a construction business once and would get anxiety over dumb things like that. Wonder how many positivereviews ?Mr Lasagna? wrote for Magones? So, here is mine and it?s all about their delicious lasagna (was absolutely phenomenal)I had over the weekend. My girlfriend got the chicken parm and loved it. I also ordered a caesar salad which was top notch. Bornand bred in NY, it?s almost impossible to find a good Italian restaurant in the south. These guys are a very close second, in myopinion. Definitely give them a shot and be objective when reading these negative reviews from the miserable souls out therewith nothing better else to do but find company to join their misery. Read more

Decent Italian food. Staff and chef were very accommodating. I will return.

Had a birthday party for my husband. 11 people in all and this place did not miss a beat! All the food was high quality, fresh... and delicious. We were not rushed so the food and appetizers were right on time. There were many other customers there enjoyingthemselves. From the Chef to the waitress were just awesome! We will be back again soon. Thanks to all the kind and generousstaff five stars all the way! Emily Fisher Ray Read more

Love Magone?s!!! Their pasta, bread, sauces and pizza are always all so good. Take out tonight was Shrimp Alfredo with... mushrooms. Loved it. Saving leftovers for lunch tomorrow. ?Lo amo!? Read more

This place is generally great, we have used them several times and been very happy. This last time we had a large order and one... of the orders was lasagna. When we got it it, it was about a quarter of the normal portion and looked like someone had beeneating off of it. Seemed we had gotten someone?s to go box in our order. We thought no big deal, we will call and they will takecare of it. No apology from the staff or Manager. They told us they could not refund us initially and offered for us to getanother lasagna but it was not convenient to pick it up so we just wanted a refund. The manager hung up and we had to call backto find out what the deal was. When we did, there was no apology ever and he stated that we will get our refund. I willdefinitely reconsider going here again, not because of the food, because of the lack of customer service upon receiving a mealthat was half eaten with no apology. Read more

The pasta was cooked perfectly. My wives chicken Parm was amazing too. She compared it to Carmines in Time Square NYC. This will... be our lunch spot from now on when we are in the area. Read more

This is my favorite Italian restaurant! I love the calzones and strombolis and the antipasto is always so fresh and a really... generous portion for the money! Everything is freshly prepared and delicious. Thank you Magone Italian grill I?m neverdissatisfied or disappointed! I?ve been ordering from this place since 2018. Read more

Great place for pasta dishes with great pizza too. Fresh salads. Delicious food. Friendly service. Don?t be fooled by the... unassuming appearance. Reasonably priced. Casual restaurant. Just a really solid spot. Read more