Reviews for Anthony's Pizza & Pasta in Centennial, CO

Update 11/15/22: We had a great experience with Anthony?s this last time. Prompt delivery and amazing pizza as always! Hate to... leave such a bad review because their pizza is amazing! Last time we ordered a pizza to be delivered at 4:15 PM they brought itat 3:30 and left it on the porch and it was very cold by the time we got it. This time we ordered a pizza to be delivered at4:15 and it never came. Called and they said that their computer crashed and I need to re-order. Re-ordered with a deliverytimer 30 minutes. I went ahead with it because he would have time to eat it before leaving the house. It took one hour and wewere unable to eat it for dinner as we had an event to get to. Disappointing because Anthony?s has amazing pizza! Will try onemore time and see how it goes. I will update if it?s a better experience. Read more

Usually good service and really good pizza but.. service was goofy today. I waited in line for a pick up and was the only one... waiting at the counter, yet she served the two people behind me first... What? When I eventually received the order, I asked tomake sure there was blue cheese included with our wings as we paid for sauce. She said yes, but there was no blue cheese to befound when we got home and opened the wings. Might be worth working on crowd control and service at the counter with theemployees, as well as double checking the orders. Great food though! Read more

This place has really surprised us! The quality of ingredients, quick production and fair pricing has all contributed to this... being our favorite place to grab pizza. Read more

I thought it would be a good idea to give this place a try despite all of the reviews i have seen. I was WRONG. The staff was... extremely nice but the food was absolutely horrendous, my pizza came burnt, half of the toppings that i ordered weren?t even onthe pizza nor cooked. Read more

I saw all the bad reviews, but tried it anyway. I shouldn't have. Ordered 12 wings, but only got 6. Two were burnt to a crisp... while the other 4 were barely cooked. Similarly, the pizza dough was barely done, but there was enough heat to release oil fromthe sausage, so ended up with an oily dough ball. It all went in the trash. Luckily it was through Doordash so got refunded.This place either needs a total makeover or shut down before someone gets seriously sick. Read more

I have been coming to this location since they opened and sad to say it is not worth coming back. Staff has always been very... nice, helpful, and incredible, but that will never out weigh the food quality becoming so subpar. Last few visits have left uswith pizzas that were totally burnt on the bottom, yet with toppings undercooked and bland on top. Despite giving many 2ndchances because things happen, constant decline in quality over months with no signs of improvement lead to seeking betteralternitives. When there are so many options for twice the food at half the cost nearby there is no value in spending so muchfor burnt pizza. Read more

I know this place has a few bad reviews, so I wanted to check it out. Our order was a Gluten-free pizza and a regular pepperoni... pizza for the kids. At time of pick up, the restaurant was clean the girl that greeted us was welcoming, and had great customerservices. Our order was correct but most important amazing. After a long day for us, a good pizza was just right. ???????????? Read more

Two stars, the crust was well-made on par as any other restaurant. But that was about it. I'm not sure if it's this location, or... another but it is Anthony's Pizza & Pasta's franchise nevertheless. Apart from the well-made crust, other are quite subpar. Thisis my first time ordering from this franchise due to a DoorDash free delivery promotion. I specifically mentioned that I wantedpepperoni and pineapple as topping ($1.00 each topping), while the pineapple was done correctly, they replaced my pepperoni withhuge slices of ham. Now I know ham arguably cost more than the pepperoni, but this is not the point, ham doesn't taste the sameas the pepperoni-- in result a bland, tasteless, and lackluster pizza. Not only they messed up the pepperoni, but also the pizzais very crudely made. The topping seemed like someone just took a huge slab of cheese, toss it onto the pizza then throws itinto the microwave (not oven); worse part is, the ham is under the cheese with the sauce. They didn't cut the pizza properly(I'm in a situation where knife is not available) so when you want to take a slice, the cheese drags the topping among the otherslices, off of the pizza because the cheese is too thick and not properly cut. This is probably the worst pizza experience Ihave ever had. I'm that type of guy who will put food in his mouth that has been made with minimum effort and still will sayit's delicious; for me to say something is poorly made, you have to really mess up. Granted, if the pizza tasted better-- allthe thick cheese, ham, and poor effort could be somewhat neglected. But so far, the only redeemable value of this pizza is thecrust, and the free delivery; however, what's the point of free deliver if the pizza is already $15 (not including tax andtips)? One can say I am a picky eater/have high standard, but again, I'm not; as I said earlier I will eat food that are madewith minimum effort and still give it a 5-stars rating. The only compelling factor for me to even Read more