Reviews for Settlers Inn in Cedarburg, WI
How do you top the best perch fry l ever had ? I chose the roasted red potatoes as a side - the best that l ever had and then... you can't beat their Cole slaw But then l saw the lemon meringue pie in the display case and if it tastes as good as it looks mywife will be lucky to get a bite Read more
My family was very pleased with the lunch catering service from Settlers Inn for our mother's funeral. The food was delicious... and delivered on time. Joan worked with us to create a meal that fit our wishes. I would highly recommend! Read more
I have never had a bad meal here. I love their food!! It?s so heartwarming and delicious. I love the space ? unique,... comfortable, very spacious and perfect for lunch with a group/family or just a couple. I also love that they have a bar ifyou?re feeling like a cocktail with brunch, good coffee and such a great menu. I can?t say enough about this special place inCedarburg. Read more
This place is soooo dope. We came in and got one of the best sandwiches we?ve ever had, and even got some fresh pasta salad with... it. The bloody Mary?s are delicious and are served with a Spotted Cow beer chaser. Read more
Love this place!!! While enjoy a lot of what they offer - the best and most amazing are their pies!!!! Amazing crust reminds me... of my grandmother and mother's! They are so good I served 30 of them at my wedding! Read more
No food on the day we visited. There were 4 of us and they had two cinnamon rolls and two muffins. Nice looking place if you... just want coffee. Read more
First time in Settlers Inn, and it was a great experience! Staff are extremely friendly, knowledgeable, and make great... recommendations. I ordered two different fish fries with two different sides, and everything tasted delicious. Their tartarsauce was excellent too. I also had to try a piece of their German Chocolate Cake, and it was to die for! I cannot wait to goback and try more of their food. Read more
Very good home-made food. Awesome service