Reviews for Out & Out Eatery and Catering in Cedarburg, WI

Great sandwiches (I used to live in Miami and Out and Out?s Cuban sandwich is pretty decent), custard and Mac & cheese. Couple... of things I don?t understand: they for rid of the outside order window ( I would prefer this to going inside during niceweather) and they got rid of the best mac&cheese, which had bacon in it. Read more

LOVED the roast beef sandwich on ciabatta! The garlic mayonnaise was distributed perfectly and all of the toppings were even!... This is probably up there with one of my favorite sandwiches, and my fiance agreed with his chipotle chicken sandwich! I tried abite of his, and I would have been just as happy ordering that one. This is the first time we have tried them, and a woman inline behind us had nothing but great things to say. It won't be our last visit! The staff was super friendly and the prices arevery reasonable. The only criticism I have is that we also tried the three cheese and chicken mac and it seemed a little bit dry(the regular one is our fave!). The chicken on it was very yummy! When I got home, I added some butter and milk and it perkedthings right up again. I can't wait to treat my parents to lunch here! Read more

This is normally an awesome and delicious place but ew. This was found in our food?. Makes me think maybe how many times I may... have missed something like this in our food. Who knows though. (After response from owner) I did not speak to a manger because Iordered take out. There was a hair found in my food. I would be open to getting my money back somehow. Read more

Great combo of veg, vegan, and standard fare. The Thai quinoa salad was delicious and substantial. Quick service, clean and... pleasant dining areas. Bit of side-eye from front desk staff, perhaps because the place is a few blocks out of the historicdistrict and I?m no longer a local In Wisconsin. Read more

I had a "Classic" Cuban" which was missing Swiss cheese. The tomato soup had too much cream, but had a good flavor. The staff... was very friendly and I didn't have to wait long for my food. Read more

Ordered catering for a graduation party including mac and cheese, wraps, sandwiches and a salad. Everything was well packed,... labeled and wonderful. The staff was very friendly and loaded the order in my car. Everyone loved the food. Highly recommend! Thank you Out and Out. Read more

Food is pretty good. A step up from fast food. But don?t waste your time and order online. You choose a time online for pick up... and then regardless of the time you choose they don?t start making it until you go inside and check in. When I went inside therewas no one at take out window. So I arrived five minutes early but had to wait in line to talk to cashier and then everyone inline gets their food before me (even the person behind me got their food before me). The food (2 Orders of Mac and cheese and 1sandwich) ended up being ready 20 minutes after my chosen ?pick up? time. Very frustrating for a person with 3 small childrenwaiting in car (then not waiting in car). Edited to add that after posting the manager reached out and explained that theexperience I had is not how their take out service usually runs, she appreciated the feedback. She sent a gift certificate inthe mail which I received today. I appreciate the follow up and am hopeful that my last experience was a fluke and I will givethem another try sometime soon. Read more

I used Out & Out to cater my daughter's graduation party ordering Mac and Cheese original, spicy chicken Mac and cheese, and the... sandwich platters. It was perfect! All of the guests loved the quality, taste, and presentation. I could not have been happier.The food pick up was easy and everything was prepared exactly right. Thank you so much Out & Out!! Read more