Reviews for Hefner's Frozen Custard & Jumbo Burgers in Cedarburg, WI

I pick up lunch for me and several co-workers, at least once a month. The food is good, no issues with anything like that.... However, there is issues with order actually being correct. On every order there is at least one thing missing, and on occasionthere are several items. Before i leave, i 100% check the entire bag for what is missing and without fail, there always issomething missing. Last 4 times i have been there at least one item isn't there, last Friday a mini taco wasnt. Friday beforethat a full bag of 4 items were forgotten. Frustrating. Even more frustrating getting back to work and somebody's $9 sandwichisn't there. Read more

Skimpy burgers, chicken tenders were burnt old oil in general, cheese curds are on point! Tacos are nasty, fry/mix was not... tasty, slushy machine broken. Read more

This place is awesome! Food is great. Ice cream is great. You can play cool retro games while you wait. My 4 year old son loves... to play pinball while we wait for the food! Read more

Always a great burger. Good variety of ice cream. Mushrooms, cheese curds and fries always hot and good. Been going there since... they opened. Read more

I like the small town local feeling of the place, the outdoor seating options (nicer than inside), and the sundae was refreshing... on a hot day. That said, the employees seemed a little spaced out, and they got my order completely wrong. While I didn't trythe hamburgers, the prices seemed rather steep. I wanted to like it more but it paled in comparison to Kopps and Culvers. Read more

Why go to Culver?s when you can have a much more authentic and bigger burger! Love this old school burger and shake spot, from... the exterior to the arcade games and inside it feels like the burger spots of the 80s and 90s! Burgers are big and there?s a lotof options, we enjoyed the Huge Hefner and the Cedar Burger! Huge Hefner is a play on the Big Mac and is wayyy better obviously,the cedar burger was good as well, the cheese sauce is pretty rich tho. Had the get a shake and an Oreo cookie sandwich too, boyare we glad we stopped! If your in the area, trust me, skip Culver?s and come here! Read more

Classic Custard and Delicious burgers. Very clean and tidy. If You love custard and hamburgers this is your place.

I was treated to Hefners for dinner and boy howdy was it a great burger joint! The restaurant has a pleasant clean aesthetic to... it and has good quick service! The food itself is very great! I had a vanilla milkshake, order of fries and double cheeseburgerwoth pickles and mustard and all tasted great and filling! Try Hefners out if you're in the area, it's great! Pictures are ofthe menu, restaurant, and food I got! Read more