Reviews for Pomodoro's Italian Eatery in Catskill, NY
I don't eat meat or much dairy. Pomodoro's spring mix salad with Bleu cheese, dried cranberries, and balsamic was tasty, filling... and not too expensive. Service was very good. Read more
My family went to Pomodoro's for dinner and at first glance we were impressed. The interior was spacious and the it looked nice.... When we sat down we were craving good pizza after previously going to Paul's, so I ordered a slice as an appetizer. Well thispizza was no better. Oregano in the sauce which was over powering, bland dough, barely palatable. Our dinners were a littlebetter but not by much. My wife got the penne ala vodka which looked like tomato sauce with cream added to it and prosciuttosprinkles on top which made it bland with the occasional salt bomb bite. I had the chicken Parm dinner which was covered intheir disgusting sauce, and I mean it was smothered in it. I had to scrap the excess sauce off. The chicken looked like it wasfrozen chicken (which I cannot say for sure it was because I am not in the kitchen). The breading was not good. The only savinggrace was the dessert. It was surprisingly good and the reason for giving it 2 stars. waitress was friendly, but a bitforgetful at times. Read more
My wife and I stopped in for some lunch. The staff greeted us nicely and our waitress was excellent and very pleasant! We have... Pasta Fazool and a chicken parm sub. Both were delicious their sauce is excellent! Read more
Went there tonight around 5:30, alone with my dog. Both outside tables were empty. A number of inside tables also empty. Went... in, asked if I could sit with my dog outside. "Sure." Then..., "Oh, but would you want a waitress?" Huh? Um, yeah I guess.After a bit of a wait while the hostess went off to check - during which two groups were seated inside - she came back to tellme "You can order take-out then sit outside." What the heck? "No service?" "No, we're just too busy." I mean, that's justtotally bizarre. A restaurant with a number of empty tables, seating walk-ins, that's "too busy" to serve a customer. I dunno,I promise I shower at least once a month whether I need it or not, and I actually got a haircut the other day. I'm a nice guy.Why such weird treatment? Not sure I'll go back.... Read more
Got take out. Calzone just thrown in a bag on a paper plate. Grease all over the bag which got on my fabric car seat. Dough... wasn't cooked enough, ricotta cheese was clumped in only one part of the Calzone and I got no side of sauce. Totallydisappointed and disgusted. Read more
The food was pretty good. There should of been some more toppings on a 28$ meat lovers pizza. But everyone liked what they did... get. The service, and atmosphere was very good ???? ????. Read more
When we visit the Catskill area, we always eat at Pomodoro's! This trip we ate there twice! It takes some time to receive your... order but that's because everything is made fresh and the quality is amazing! The stars of the show are the meatballs. You HAVEto add them to your meal. Read more
Usually one of our favorite places. We have been here 20 times. Disappointing experience. Long wait at table before order. Food... was subpar from our usual experience. Dinner was very bland. We ordered drinks but were rarely checked on. We were charged apremium price. Our typical experience has been positive. We will try one more time. 12.3.22 Read more