Reviews for Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church in Castle Rock, CO

This was our first time here. We loved it. Our server was the best. The calamari was delicious. The garlic bread was great. ... I had Stuffed shrimp as did my husband. My daughter had the spaghetti bolognese and my son in law had the linguini carbonara.Everything was delicious. The atmosphere was great. I can't wait to go back. Read more

We had a party of six for a birthday celebration here on a Sunday night. (9-4-2022) The place was very busy and very loud. In... fact, it was so loud that one side of our table could not hear what the folks on the other side of the table were saying most ofthe evening. The appetizers were good, but the main dishes were just average. When we arrived, we entered on the right side ofthe building, which is the bar area. We had a drink and waited for the rest of our party to arrive. While sitting there, wewatched the cooks making pizza. I was rather dismayed to see them kneading the dough for the pizza with bare hands. I thoughtall restaurant workers had to use some sort of gloves when making pizza dough. There is one bright spot though. Our waitresswas very kind and worked very hard to serve us for about 2 hours. I complimented her and provided a generous tip when we left. Ithink this place would be fine for lunch, but it may be overrated for dinner. One last note, parking is not easy in this areaof town. We got lucky and found a spot on the street. ???????? Read more

This was a wonderful place to celebrate Father's Day! The food was impeccable and the service incredible! The venue is beautiful... with stained glass windows and dark wood but done in a modern, comfortable way. Indoor and outdoor seating is available as wellas seating at the bar, which is modern and comfortable. We sat at a charming, cozy, two-person table right under a stained glasswindow. Our server, Gavin, started us with a taste of their homemade red wine which is sweet and dessert-like. We ordered warm,cheesey garlic bread, crusty with sesame seeds. Dippable in a fresh, bright tomato sauce. I enjoyed the gnocchi with Alfredosauce, which had an unusual flavor, maybe nutmeg, bursting through. They were very soft and stuck to the roof of the mouth, butdelicious comfort food. My husband enjoyed his chicken parmesan tremendously. Both meals made excellent leftovers later asserving sizes were quite generous. Honestly, the highlight of the meal was the creamy, fantastic cheesecake! Obviously homemadewith love! Swooning! Best ever! Gavin was so fun and gracious and we had an awesome time! Read more

Cool thing about this place is it was an old church that was converted into a restaurant. Some of the better Italian style food... I have had in a long time. I ordered the Veal Saltimbocca. This is a very rich dish. The Veal was cooked to perfection andthe sauce was rich and creamy. There bread was light fluffy. Although the Veal was amazing I think the star of the meal wasthe Balsamic reduction and oil dipping sauce. If you do get a chance to dine here make full use of that dipping sauce and planto leave full. Read more

I've been meaning to write this review for a long time. I've been to Scileppi's about 7 times now. It just might be my favorite... Italian restaurant of all time. The atmosphere is perfect. It's a great place to take a date or visitors because it's reallyunique and memorable. Moving on to the food. Scileppi's food is almost too good. They have the classic italian dishes you'dexpect, as well as their own unique dishes. Their red sauce is great, their lemon white wine butter sauce is amazing, you reallywon't go wrong. The wines and cocktails are fantastic too. It's the type of place that requires multiple revisits, and you'llnever be disappointed that you went back. Plus, the staff is very friendly and helpful. Read more

The waitress was amazing. I can't remember her name. Even though she was knew she seemed like a season vet.... courtesy...knowledgeable.. attentive. the vibe of the place was busy but still comfortable. the food was great. the orangeCreamsicle cake was beyond words.. will come back Read more

A unique atmosphere for a meal in downtown Castle Rock. The food was excellent and the service was quick. We split a variety... of dishes to try a few different items. Our favorite was the app was the truffle fries and our favorite main was the lobsterravioli. Read more

I popped in here on a whim the other say with a friend. It was pretty busy but we sat at the bar and still received excellent... service. The appetizers are great and decently priced and the bartender was attentive and made great suggestions for drinks. Thefood was pretty good and came in large portions as well. I'm sure this place is always busy, so try for a reservation if you canjust to make sure you get the opportunity to try this place. The interior is beautiful as well, bring that it's it's old church.It's very comfortable and has a great atmosphere. What really pushed this review to q 5 star is that I noticed several regularsreturning and the excellent attention each staff member gave to customers. Above and beyond really, I'll happily come back whenin the area! Read more