Reviews for Original Anthony's NY Pizza in Casselberry, FL
Every single time I eat here, I swear the food makes me HAPPY! You know when you want to do a little dance in your seat because... everything down to the detail is excellent? Like that. Not to mention, Cheryl is the best! Very attentive, knowledgeable andhilarious! Read more
Best Chicken parm around!. I get mine with ziti. Fresh and tasty every time. Didn?t expect that from a little pizza shop in a... shopping center. Their pasta sauce is delicious and so is their white pizza. I even enjoy their side salad with ranch. 2 serversthere are always very nice. This is one place I actually visit regularly.. Read more
Save yourself a headache and tummy ache, go somewhere else!!! We ordered a pizza and it came like this, so politely I called to... make them aware. Immediately the lady says no refunds. Finally, she agreed to make a cheese pizza replacement. I go to pick itup and she gives me complete hell saying she shouldn?t give me the new pizza cos the pizza shown below is cooked and nothingwrong with it. Mind you, I brought it back as is not even one bite taken because the pizza clearly is not cooked. Wait it getsbetter. She opened the new pizza she was going to give us since they originally messed up. She proceeds to open it and pull upthe crust to prove this one is cooked. No gloves, no hand washing. This lady literally rang a lady out with cash right beforeshe took care of me. Lady, you are working the front register, people are coming in and out, you?re handling money and touchingthose pens that people use to sign right before I came to the counter. I get that everyone has a bad day but if you?re themanager for 36 years at this establishment like you kept screaming at me then you should stand behind your product with customerservice and never cross contaminate money handling and food handling. Service is garbage, food is without a doubt crosscontaminated. I saw with my own two eyes. Read more
Everything was absolutely delicious. My family and I enjoyed. When we're in the area again we'll definitely stop by.
****update**** got the Anthony?s extravaganza and it was really good. Sub mushrooms for japs. Pizza had a nice crisp and the... dough was tasty, fresh ingredients. Staff was great and let my son fold boxes. We had a good time?only complaint is we got 2soda waters and they charged us almost $5. I know this is debatable but my argument anywhere I go is if it is not listed as acost in the soda section then it should be like water. Free I like this place. The people who work there are really nice, Theranch is really good and the portion size is really good. The pizza is good, fresh ingredients and tasty. Read more
One of the best pies around! Their sauce is delicious and their dough is crunchy and bubbly. They are generous with their cheese... and you get that pull apart cheesy goodness while the dough is still crispy and hot. The staff is very friendly and willing togo out their way to make their customers feel both welcome and satisfied. We had a special request and they were game for it!!!Super cool and family oriented so bring your folks down and have a great experience! Read more
We've both eaten in and gotten takeout here. Always amazing. We drive 20 minutes and pass several other pizza places to go here.... I would have easily given 5 stars for those visits. But this visit was not the same at all. The plain pizza was overcooked andthe crust on both pies tasted over proofed. The supreme did have a lot of toppings but they were unevenly distributed in randomclumps. Like all the mushrooms were in one spot, the cheese in another etc. And the garlic knots barely had any garlic or butterand were tough. Previously they came baked together, and you would pull the roll off and they were soft and delicious andcovered in garlic. These came as individual knots that had some garlic powder sprinkled on top. We were really disappointed. Didthey get new owners? Read more
Cheryl the waitress was wonderful with the quick service and pleasant personality. She is a true asset to this restaurant and... I'm sure all the clients love her. The food was cooked to perfection and the restroom was just as lovely as any ladies roomshould be. The prices are a tiny bit over but all in all as well worth it. Wonderful service, great food and lovely atmosphere. Read more