Reviews for Anthony's Pizza in Casselberry, FL
They do have new york pizza I'm from ozone Park queens I work as pizza man for 17 years I say it's best I had in 15 years in... Florida I just wish worker was more friendly and pizza guys I want them to know they have best pizza anywhere . price was bestme and my 2 kids I'll be back and zeppoles grandma pie Read more
I ordered a few things that I usually get from the anthonys that served the area that I moved from (oviedo) That location was... jam up. unfortunately I was disappointed with the quality of the food I recieved this evening. everything was horrible so Idon't know where to start. the calizone was still cold inside, I thought that I had ordered a side of Alfredo sauce but its asoup I guess? it was no thicker than a glass of milk and flavor was not present. The calamari came in a small to go box,portion wise its deff not worth the price. usually they send it with lemons or something to garnish the appetizer, this hadnothing. cold as well. I don't even want to start with how bad the lasagna was. but deffinatly won't be spending 60 bucks thereagain. needless to say I am more than disappointed with the food I recieved. Read more
My family and I have regularly visited this place for many years. The pasta is always cooked flawlessly, the sauce isn't... "sweet". The pies are PHENOMENAL (order "The Don"....yw)! Just a great little Italian joint that SHOULD always be packed butisn't. Read more
Simply one of the best. Last week I tried the chicken cacciatore and it was awesome! One of my sons had a Stromboli and I got... the leftovers. OMG, it too was delicious. All I have had in the past is their delicious pizza by the slice, but since this wasour second trip in a week, bringing guest along, I thought I?d try the pasta. No disappointments here. Read more
Expensive for NO REASON? ordered two slices which totaled over $10. One slice was a simple regular cheese slice. I?m from... Brooklyn so I?m like ok, must be dam good tasting pizza? nope! It was basic similar to school lunch pizza. Go to Russo?s inWinter Springs. Great NY taste for half the price. I should never had ventured off?. Read more
A week ago I got a pasta dish and ended up sick from it. Today my company wanted to order pizza and we made a simple order of... half the pizza with bacon and pepperoni light sauce and the other half with tomato, olive, and spinach. When we got the pizzathe whole thing was loaded bacon and pepperoni. We called and they made a new pizza however they still didnt put the olives onand instead of giving us fresh tomatoes they put weird tomato sauce goop on top. Gave them 2 tries within an hour it seems likethey were more petty than trying to give good customer service. You can tell the first pizza was fresh but the one they remadewas a ?screw you we dont have time for you pizza?. I was willing to give a second chance after getting sick from the pasta butafter 3 chances I will never go here again. Read more
What happened to this Anthony?s? Ordered the lunch special today, 2 slices of pep and a house salad with a side container of... Italian dressing. Ate the pizza which was good, but the salad was rancid. Before I could add the dressing, noticed the Tomatoeswere covered in a milky white film, cucumber slices were translucent & mushy, there was a slimy yellow liquid pooled in thecontainer?s bottom and the smell was putrid. I called, let the staff know, and suggested they check all their saladimmediately. If I ate this salad I imagine I?d need my stomach pumped. For months I?ve been avoiding this Anthony?s, after mylast Large stromboli order was easily HALF the size of what I?ve been getting there multiple times a year for 10+ years. I tookit back and the cook told me it was the right size. BS. For years, my wife and I were stuffed after sharing one, the last onewas barely enough for one person. Read more
So , I accidentally ordered the wrong pizza for lunch. I spoke to the server that it was my fault and to charge me for both.... They did not charge, honest mistake. The pizza that i did eat was the special and it was out of this world good. I will be backmany times. Everyone super nice, fast service and delicious food. Thank you Read more