Reviews for Alfano's Pizza Restaurant in Carthage, IL

My friend and I went here for lunch before doing Christmas shopping. The waitstaff were all very friendly. The food was very... good. I got the focaccia. I wasn't sure how I felt about lettuce on basically a calzone, but this was very nice! I would totallyget it again. Read more

Absolutely LOVE the pizza here and stuffed breadsticks. Great prices and the staff are always helpful and nice.

If you're from Fort Madison and you miss sorrento's ,the Alfano family were the original owners of sorrento's, give them a try,... they have 5 locations in the area Read more

Visiting from Georgia, love this restaurant! Great food, good service. My only issue is they charge after your first refill on... drinks. Other than that, great place. Read more

Lasagna is his favorite, mine was Spaghetti but new forever favorite is Spinach Ravioli. Wish we could have had Tarimessu.... Theirs is excellent. Service top notch, famous food, pleasant atmosphere. We enjoy going here Read more

FANTASTIC service from Jade and great food! Came in with a group of 12 adults and 3 kids- Everything we ordered came out... quickly, hot and delicious! Jade was super attentive and quick with all of our requests. If I lived closer this would definitelybe a regular dinner spot for me! Read more

Well 4yrs ago I wrote a 1 star review for Alfanos Pizza in Carthage and swore to myself I'd avoid that place like the... plague. Today I returned and was fed a huge plate of my least favorite meal...crow. (definitely figuratively speaking herefolks! The meal was delicious! Just keep reading and you'll see...) You enter the restaurant and immediately are welcomed withthe aroma of Italian seasoning in the air, your eyes witness several groups of families and friends enjoying their mealslaughing or in deep conversations. Looking around, the tables are separated to encourage social distancing masks are requiredbut quickly come off at the right time. Our server, Tia, takes our order and she is polite, funny and gives a thumbs up on the Caribbean Pulled Pork sandwich. I saw how busy Tia was, going from table to table tending to her customers every needs. I evenheard someone mention the word understaffed amongst the customers, so I braced myself for a long wait on the food. To mysurprise our perky server dropped our food off not long after ordering! It looked delicious! And it was! My coworkers pizza wasjust as tempting, a variety of ingredients topping it with copious mouth watering amounts. The meal, the humorous waitress and awarm atmosphere really changed my mind about my previous experience and now the only thing left to do is finish this plate ofcrow I've been served!???? Great job Tia and staff! Thanks to the owner, whom I heard was actually cooking that day, forproviding an enjoyable service to the community! Read more

Great family spot! Try the garlic cheese knots!! Sauce was amazing on everything! Great service from Tia and everyone there. Get... off the interstate and try it!! Read more