Reviews for Fentoni's Pizza in Carolina Beach, NC
Awesome NY style pizza!!! If I lived local, this would be my official pizza place. Prices are totally reasonable for being so... close to the beach and with current costs of goods. Around $10 for a couple of slices and a drink. Was a slow time when westopped but you can tell these cats are typically on point!! Food was great and quick, and the place was super clean (includingthe bathroom!). Highly recommend! Read more
3 slices of pepperoni and 1 cheerwine in a clear cup. Nothing better! My son and I love coming here on the weekends to share... lunch. Logan and the crew are always kind to cut his slice up into bite-sized pieces since he?s a toddler. Best pizza on theisland for us! Read more
Great service on our delivery from the young lady who answered the phone to the gentleman who delivered. Pizza was fantastic,... easily one of the best I?ve ever had with fresh ingredients piled high. A little pricey for pizza but worth every penny. Read more
Best NY style pizza I've ever had! The bottom crust was thin with a slight crisp and the outer crust was beautifully done. You... can get two pieces of pepperoni and two drinks for $13 total. Makes for a great light dinner that leaves room for the amazingdonuts next door. Read more
Great NY style pizza. Amazed at the price of $16 for the three of us including drinks. Being from NYC I wanted that crunch on... the crust Read more
Fentoni?s pizza is a good spot for pizza. Located near the carolina beach boardwalk right next to Britt?s donuts! Order your... pizza, then pop next door to get your mouth watering donuts for dessert! The employees are always very nice and helpful! Enjoyyour pizza! Read more
Here is what to expect for dine in at Fentoni's pizza. They may or may not be open during posted business hours, you have to... show up to find out if open or not. The restrooms for the dine in patrons is locked with a key coded numerical keypad that is aclosely guarded secret, so sacred that an employee will be required to punch it in for you, lest you let all your friends intothe pizza parlor bathrooms. Paying cash? Nothing over a $10 bill will be accepted, and in all cases no change will be given asall cash sales are rounded up in their favor due to (according to Fentoni's), the big national money shortage. How was thepizza? Have no idea, we only had a $50 bill to pay with and they refused to make the $10 in change our pizza purchase would haverequired. Did glance at a table on the way out, it appeared ny style with plenty of orange grease. Can't recommend this placeunfortunately. *Edit to my review, as the owner has replied: Also expect the owner of this pizza parlor to show his truefeelings about his customers if you mention their policies publicly. He clearly despises those whom he is tasked with serving.Good luck pal, your rage is misplaced. Read more
Husband loves the Sicilian pizza during off season. I had salad was tasty just found out that they have gluten free options as... well. Read more