Reviews for Tomatoes II Pizzeria in Carnegie, PA
We've eaten here a handful of times over the years. Unfortunately, after this most recent order we'll probably take our business... elsewhere. When we called and placed the order, we were told our total. Upon picking up and paying, they changed us anadditional 80 cents, different from what they told us our total would be. We were told this was a fee for paying with a creditcard. You gotta be transparent with your customers. Oh, and the garlic knots had no flavor. The pizza had little to no sauce. Read more
Owners are so nice and attentive. Any issues I?ve ever had have been reassured with great customer service. staff is always nice... and thoughtful. Great food too! Read more
I tried it today for the first time and everything I got was good pizza wings and a hoagie plus the price wasn't outrageous like... some other places around I will be back to try more soon keep up the good work Read more
Went there about 4 weeks ago and didn't feel good afterwards. Wasn't ready to blame anyone. But got a hogie and wings 2 days ago... and ended up in St. Clair hospital with food poisoning. Only thing I ate all day, so there is no doubt it was from there food.STAY AWAY! Read more
Tomatoes ll is one of my favorite pizza shops in Carnegie! The quality of their food is absolutely excellent and always tastes... great. I highly recommend trying their wings some time. You won?t regret it! The employees are very friendly as well???? Read more
I'm sorry but their wings are the worst I've ever had in the Pittsburgh area. Soggy, weirdly breaded, not crispy at all like... they are supposed to be. They also shorted us a wing, which I didn't mind because they weren't good at all anyway. They musthave coated them in a lot of flour instead of just cornstarch which is how they are supposed to be done. Also, much tooexpensive for what they are. Don't waste your money on them. I don't think their cook has any idea how wings are supposed tobe made, I would happily share a recipe with them. Two stars because the celery and blue cheese were fine and the pizza smelledgood. I think they should take wings off their menu. Read more
One of the best pizza deliveries in the south hills. We ordered the spinach and feta pizza with white sauce and enjoyed it. What... exceeded our expectations was the breaded zucchini planks and hot pepper cheese balls. Typically by the time it?s delivered toyour house, deep fried appetizers tend to lose their crispness and become soft but not Tomatoes! Our zucchini planks and cheeseballs arrived super crisp and hot just like if would have been dining in. Big thumbs up for figuring that out! Read more
Tomatoes II pizza in Carnegie is good pizza. The crust is awesome and the sauce is not overwhelmingly sweet. Garlic knots, ... pepperoni puffs and the cinnamon sugar puffs were all delicious. Read more