Reviews for Slice on Broadway - East Liberty in Carnegie, PA
The pizza is fantastic! Crispy crust with a thicker crust option if you like that, too! But steer clear of the chicken parm.... It's processed,pre-made and frozen chicken patties. Not worth the price for me. Try the pepperoni rolls, though! Read more
Everyone was really friendly!!! Such a cute part of Carnegie I had never been to before. A little heavier on the sauce than the... Wexford location. The garlic knots were AMAZING. It was a true NY pizza experience which we have been searching for! Read more
Slice on Broadway is a Thin crust, New York style pizza shop. The pizza is simple but done well. The sauce and cheese on the... slices are good quality and work well together. The crust has a Semolina/Sourdough type taste to it. They provide a goodsauce/cheese to crust ratio. Very foldable slices. It’s not a greasy slice either - unless you add Pepperoni ofcourse. Usually they have individual slices and rolls available to those who walk in. The Pepperoni and Steak/Onion rolls areabove average. They have great Ranch dressing for all of the fans out there as well. Prices have gone up recently, but thequality has stayed on point here. Definitely worth a visit for a slice! Read more
It look better outside then inside. when I go inside I am not sure do I still want to eat here or not. But I bought a pizza... anyway and I am glad that I went in lol. It is one of the best pizza that I had. Read more
Fantastic pizza & subs. Very freindly staff. Nice little neighborhood pizzeria.
Pizza was pretty good! We got a half and half pizza. I just got cheese and pep on mine...since this was my first time there I... wanted to test it out. I forgot what my better half got, but she made hers a bit more exotic. We ate in, so the pizza was veryhot when served to us. Note to self...wait for it to cool a bit before digging in or else all the toppings will slide right offlol...my mistake! Friendly people at the counter. The only small gripe was the price (I believe it was a $1 for each additionaltopping, so that adds up quick if you customize quite a bit). Other than that it was a great little place! I'll be back! Read more
Usually it is good pizza but this time way way too peppery and greasy. The garlic knots were doughy and undercooked. Terrible... cannoli. It was soggy and the filling was broken, chunky and runny. It was a waste of money. Read more
Slice on Broadway has the absolute best Italian hoagie. Sooooo *%&*$ good! The dressing they use is phenomenal. It's by far the... best dressing I've ever had. EVER. All the components of this hoagie are the most superior of their kind. Put together..... It'sTHE most delightful thing my taste buds have ever come into contact with. Obviously, I'm highly recommending it. Read more