Reviews for Sal's Pizza in Carmel Hamlet, NY
We ordered the Chicken Parm pasta dinner for 2 so good, came with bread and salad their house dressing is amazing and there is... plenty of leftovers!! Read more
Ordered a chicken parmigiana with spaghetti and instead got dried spaghetti with bits of chicken and no sauce
The review from Christine Stone is dead wrong. Unfortunately I was a witness to her ?Karen? showing while my family and I were... simply trying to enjoy our delicious meal from Sal?s that NEVER lets us down. I am an advocate for good businesses. Sal?s neverdisappoints and if something is accidentally messed up they will replace it immediately or offer a credit in the future. I havebeen a customer for 20+ years. Of course they will not accommodate disrespectful customers that yell at the young counterworkers, that is the only reason I can see this business not replacing or crediting their FRESH food. Read more
This place is great and the meatballs are 100% homemade you can watch them make them lol please remember that this place and... all other small businesses are peoples livelihood, be respectful or do yourself and everyone else a favor and stay home! Read more
Worst food and most rude service imaginable! Pizza was cold, had to ask for it to be heated twice. Meatballs are NOT homemade,... they?re the commercial frozen kind with fillers. Fried zucchini was burnt. Girl behind the counter was super rude! Asked ifwe wanted the food we couldn?t eat (99% of it) boxed and we told her no, it was horrible. She snapped back ?I didn?t ask howit was!? Do yourself and your stomach a favor and don?t eat here! Read more
I ordered a Sicilian margarita pizza this evening and we get home and open the box, it was a large pie. I call them and the... girl tells me "oh you changed your mind about the margarita pizza and ordered a large pie instead". I told her "NO, I didn'tchange my mind. Why would I be calling you to tell you that the order is wrong??? So she then proceeds to tell me "Oh, I musthave heard you wrong".....Clearly she did....just lost a long time customer!!! Read more
I drive a bus and came down to Carmel on a sports trip. Forgot my lunch at home. Checked the reviews and whether they delivey.... They did and they showed up in a timely manner but I'm stuck wondering how to eat this fettuccine alfredo without a fork, aknife or even a napkin. Guess I'll try to reheat it tonight and review how it tastes at that time. Read more
Great pizza! Staff is friendly and attentive. Tip jar theme is rotated and a fun touch!