Reviews for Pueblo Viejo in Carmel Hamlet, NY
Mexican and a movie is always a great combo with the wife. Omar is a great host with a fantastic tequila collection. ... Especially wonderful is Fortileza in the bar. Plentiful chips and salsa and huge tasty portions. Read more
Great service, delicious food. The tacos were yummy and the burrito bowls were huge. Colorful atmosphere.
Ordered take out and the food came burned. The nachos are blackened. The flautas are slimy. Not worth the money. Lost my... appetite as soon as I saw it. Read more
I live in Brewster but was running errands in Carmel today and popped in for the first time for lunch. Everything was fresh and... perfectly prepared. Chips were fresh, salsa was fresh, Enchiladas were AMAZING! I?ll be traveling to Carmel now for Mexicanfood. The best for miles and miles! I?ll be back with friends. The tequila bar looked fully stocked with Tequilas I?ve neverseen before. Can?t wait to try! Read more
Amazing Selection of Tequila, Mezcal and more... Always a great time with wonderful people. Some comment below complaining about... Ceviche and let mentell you. Every place does a unique version. This one was amazing and delicious my 2nd time ordering it.Highly recommended. Read more
I live 45 minutes away from Carmel but work there. I had a gift certificate that I won and decided to pick up something tonight... (8/5/22) and give them a try. I took it all the way home before eating anything and I have to say it is some of the best Mexicanfood I have ever had. I kept my order simple and I left with so much food I had to question if they gave the right bag. Now Ireally want to go and eat in and try some new things. Read more
Great atmosphere , great staff! Prices are reasonable and Portions are just right. Definitely grab a grande margarita over a... regular you won?t regret it. Guacamole is made right in front of you so you know it?s not store bought Read more
3 stars for amazing decor, great service and good margaritas. The food is meh, had steak, chicken and paella. All over cooked.... All the meat and seafood is dry and flavorless. You can tell that the rice from The paella is cooked separately and just toppedoff with seafood and chorizo, it doesn?t have flavor. $125 on 3 meals 1 drink. I won?t be returning. Read more