Reviews for Prato Trattoria in Carmel Hamlet, NY
A friend recommended Prato Trattoria and we were very impressed. Once you walk through the pizzeria front, you enter a ... beautiful dining room reminiscent of Italy. The specials of the day board was brought to the table and they all lookeddelicious. I opted for the stracciatella ala Romano soup and grilled octopus for an entree. Both were excellent. Also, thehomemade olive bread was delicious. They also had all the traditional Italian specialties you would expect on the regular menu.I would definitely recommend this place for anyone wanting real Italian food prepared by a real chef. The waitress and theowner/chef were very attentive and friendly. Read more
OMG!!! It?s like the best Arthur Avenue pizza but way up in the Hudson Valley. We come to shoot at the various ranges up here, ... but we only learned lately about this place. The sauce on the pizza, the thinness of the crust, the perfect char on thedough?ALL PERFECTION! I can?t wait to try their veal dishes. There?s plenty of parking and the staff were all friendly andattentive. It?s a fantastic gem of a place. A real gastro landmark. Don?t miss out on this one. Read more
Prato is a nice lil find tucked into small shopping center... offering some pretty solid Italian classics. The ambiance is a... bit loud but not in a bad way and the decor is welcoming. Our waiter was attentive n friendly so all in all a good start. Weordered of the specials to start w/ arancini being the choice app. They came out rather timely... they were sausage n broccolirabe stuffed I believe n overall the flavor was very good though I felt they could have gone a little longer and had a more aldente risotto as it was a bit gummy. Our entrees all came out at the same time and were very well executed. Each dish had theright seasoning and depth of flave that you look for in good cooking. Homemade pastas were good and personally my scarpareillowas delicious. Will definitely be returning again soon. Read more
I happened to be up in Carmel, NY as my tattoo artist has a shop there. I was starving and wanted Italian. (*Do NOT let the... plaza type restaurant pizza shop up front fool you!!) In the back behind the pizza shop is this warm cozy little spot serving uphot plates of delicious Italian cuisine!!!! My server Celia was amazing! It was packed and I see why. I started withMozzarella Carrozza. Delicous.... fried cheese is everything!!! I ordered the Chicken Sorrentina which Celia recommended. Iwanted more it was THAT GOOD! Pictures do not do this hidden place any justice!! You must come here for yourself!! Food,ambiance and service! A1. I will be back???????? Read more
Delicious pizza. We also had to order some items from the catering with only 30 minutes of notice and they sure made it happen.... Fast and yummy. We ordered penne vodka with grilled chicken, Caesar salad and garlic bread. Their food is very good! Read more
Stopped by for some slices. Amazing service, and amazing pizza. Buffalo chicken and Chicken, bacon, ranch were loaded with... toppings. 100% would recommend for everybody! Read more
Update. Time and time again I keep coming back for more. I already left a review but I feel I didn?t do Prato justice. Let?s... break down the actual pizza. 1. The cheese - Amazing. Not to oily. Not to chewy. Very enjoyable flavor. 2. The flop - Verygood! Sturdy enough to taco but you?d have to use two hands. The actual size of the pizza is above average you get a lot forwhat you?re ordering. 3. The sauce - This is where Prato gets me every time. There must be something in the sauce because eachbite is bursting with bold flavors. 4. Toppings - if you?re going for a traditional pepperoni pie you?re in the right place.They somehow have managed to achieve the perfect cheese to sauce to toppings ratio this side of the Mississippi. Honestly I?dput them in my top 5 favorite pizza contenders. 5. The crust - Superb! I wish the crust was a little thinner but it?s crunchywith an excellent chew experience. Suggestion... keep doing what you?re doing Customer service... always delightful andnice. Original review. Nothing like crushing a pizza at the end of a long work day. Prato knows how to make a perfect slice.Even the crust makes you want to chew extra long just to enjoy the flavor. Definitely will be going back. Yes $18 for a largepepperoni pizza is a little on the expensive side but it?s worth it. Staff is nice as well! Read more
The food was delicious and the service was great. Small little quaint place. Nice ambiance. Been there twice and will definitely... go back. Delicious Italian food. Read more