Reviews for McCarthy's Grill House in Carmel Hamlet, NY
Great food and great service! Their corned beef Reuben was delicious. I attended the Putnam County Libertarian Party convention... here and saw Larry Sharpe speak. Read more
Classic neighborhood Pub in the very best sense! Comfortable, tasty food, and fine service with a smile. Worth a try for sure!!
Taco Tuesday had $10 for 3 tacos, $5 margarita. Great for a cheap date haha.
Always love McCarthy's. Stopped for dinner after a movie 2 days post St. Patricks and still going strong. The pub style food is... great as well as all the servers. Read more
Nice place. I Googled outdoor dining near me" and found this place. Here are some pictures of the outdoor area. It was a... beautiful sunny day. They had a really good BBQ pulled pork on a pretzel bun. They make you sanitize when you come in whichseems scared but the staff was friendly. Read more
Solid Irish fare with tender loving care! About five beers on tap and cocktails from the full bar. Al fresco dining out back.... Friendly though undermanned waitstaff. Clean bathrooms. Parking tight along the side on the incline. Fair prices and exquisitecatering available. On August 17th, 2019 Larry Sharpe appeared here during his second FullSharpe tour. Read more
Excellent Irish fare at very reasonable prices. Helpful manager who delayed the food's service due to us being slightly behind... schedule. Full bar with several beers on tap. Spacious area for cocktailing or conferencing. Clean bathrooms and friendlywaitstaff. Parking ample but a little tricky as it is all on an incline. After his historic run for NY Governor, Larry Sharpeappeared here on August 17th, 2019. Read more
I think i was expecting more of a homey vibe both in a restaurant as well as in food taste. Overall ok, but nothing thrilling.... Regular cheeseburger had just meet and cheese (no onion no tomato no lettuce, weird?). Nothing very homemade, really. Do notcome with a dog- not allowed inside, outside inly one table on the dirt spot, chairs dusty not wiped. Waitress very junior. Suchplaces i call them ?too far too close?. Too far from the city to hold city standards (although prices like in the city) - tooclose to have the country vibe and taste. Read more