Reviews for Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard in Carmel, IN

I can't say enough great things about Rita's! It's such a great experience when you walk in. The owner is incredible and the... staff is so friendly and wonderful. The Gelati is now my all time favorite treat! Read more

Tgis store had more flavors than the one in fishers, but still the same Freibdly experience.

Amazing! It was a suggested add on to my food from doordash. The Gelati came before my food!! Plus it was perfectly packaged to... not spill or melt. They seriously went above and beyond, I wish some restaurants took the time they did. If you've never had agelati, it will change your life!!! Read more

As a girl from Philly I am so grateful that Rita?s is here in Indy!! My favorite summer (and winter) treat! Grace does an... amazing job of developing delicious flavors. The whole crew is friendly and even make chocolate when you call ahead! Read more

We were in Indianapolis for a baseball tournament and came to Carmel art district to explore and found Rita's we were very... impressed. We stopped by twice at our trip.I especially enjoyed the coconut ice Read more

Simply amazing ice creams and service. I couldn?t recommend it enough.

I tried it for the first time last week and IT WAS AMAZING! The owners are AWESOME and were so helpful and warm. They let us try... ANY of the flavors and were just so sweet. We went back the next day and will ONLY go to this Rita?s because the owners wereamazing. I personally think this one is the one to go to in Indy. This has become an addiction to us. We LOVE IT! Read more

For a hot summer afternoon what better than a Ritas ice cream in Carmel. They also have a location in Fishers. I tried the... peach and mango flavor. reminds you of ice cream in italy. Read more